Which Italian restaurant to pick?

[marvin12]

We are 2 adults, and would love some help picking a Italian Restaurante. We have been to Disney many times but have not eaten at any of the Italian restaurants in many years . We would love some help!
Thanks

 

[FCDub]

Il Mulino

 

[pattyw]

Agree with @FCDub - Il Mulino is a step above the other Disney Italian restaurants.

 

[illinidp]

Another vote for Il Mulino

 

[punkin712]

No question - Il Mulino!

 

[goofyintoronto]

I've never been to Il Mulino....but I do loooooove Via Napoli for both pizza and pasta. Delish!

 

[ForEver2016]

Another vote for Il Mulino

 

[JerseyJanice]

My house Sunday afternoon.

Oh, you were asking about Disney World. PPs are correct. Il Mulino is the best there.

 

[glocon]

Never been to Il Muno, but the saltimbocca at Mama Melrose’s at HS is divine.

 

[gharter]

If you are not on the DDP, then Il Mulino at the Swan. Great food and service.
If you are on the DDP, then probably Tutto Italia in Italy. If you are looking for pizza, then Via Napoli.

 

[alltwelve]

Another vote for Il Mulino!

 

[marvin12]

Jersey-Janice, I’m sorry your not on the list. I bet it’s the best Sunday dinner. I appreciate all the help.thanks

 

[Linleedo]

Via Napoli has delicious pizza, "gravy",like my husband's granny used to make( he flashed back and smiled like the food critic from Ratatouille)and super flat pieces of chicken for the chicken parmigiana and other dishes. It's a good restaurant with good food. But, it seems that a lot of people sit back , drink wine, and get louder and louder. I get it. They're on vacation. Downfall-it's super loud and hard to hear each other speak, even at the same table . Tutto Italia and Mama Melrose seemed like an Olive Garden- just ok. This trip , we are trying I'll Mulino. It's worth a try.

 

[DVC_Dad_Canada]

Enzo's hideaway Sunday Supper sounds like a good option as well.

 

[Dean Marino]

If you are not on the DDP, then Il Mulino at the Swan. Great food and service.
If you are on the DDP, then probably Tutto Italia in Italy. If you are looking for pizza, then Via Napoli.

THIS... hands down, Il Mulino at the Swan is not just the BEST Real Italian Restaurant on WDW property.... Our personal opinion is that it is the ONLY REAL ITALIAN RESTAURANT on property.

Please? Go here .

TIW accepted - no DDP.
Wife and I have made about 26 visits over 13 years - from MI.
I am raised Sicilian - San Francisco.
Keep the kids away from the Limoncello .

 

[CynBeth]

Tutto Italia at Epcot!

 

[Farro]

If Il Mulino (new york) is the same one that used to be in Chicago, come on, it's not that great!

But I have not eaten at the Orlando location so I may be wrong.

OP - I would try either one of the two new restaurants that opened in Disney Springs, with the nod to Enzo's Hideaway - the menu looks fantastic. Although Terralina's menu looks really good too....

 

[mi*vida*loca]

We love via Napoli for pizza. My aunt and uncle ate their pasta dishes and said they were amazing.

Il Mulino is on my list of places to try next trip. I’ll be doing same day adr for that.

 

[PPFlight75]

We love Il Mulino. It has been the favorite of our last 2 trips.

 

[Pygoplites]

If Il Mulino (new york) is the same one that used to be in Chicago, come on, it's not that great!

But I have not eaten at the Orlando location so I may be wrong.

OP - I would try either one of the two new restaurants that opened in Disney Springs, with the nod to Enzo's Hideaway - the menu looks fantastic. Although Terralina's menu looks really good too....

Yes, you are wrong. The short-lived Il Mulino in Chicago was a more formal--and ridiculously overpriced--restaurant. The Orlando outpost is their less formal Trattoria Il Mulino brand and is consistently excellent. Terralina looks good and Tony Mantuano is a great chef, but it will have to be extremely good to surpass Il Mulino.