A different perspective. We played both. My kids loved the Pirate's Adventure! It was easier IMO, wasn't as time-consuming, and definitely contained in a smaller area! My kids were able to complete all the missions and get the end "prize". We all had a lot of fun doing it. They enjoyed Agent P also, but we split the World Showcase between two different days so they didn't get to complete it in one go. Also Agent P was more difficult for them and needed a lot more "hands on" from the parents (in our experience anyway).