I agree with dakcp2001, all the shows are amazing! We decided to go with the Illuminations dessert party for a couple of reasons. Illuminations is one of my favorite firework shows, we will be having around 50 guests and I don't think any of the boats can fit that many people for a Wishes dessert party. Also, our reception is going to be at the Living Seas, so it would be much easier to just walk over to the dessert party than to make everyone get on another bus again. Good luck with your decision!