Which Do I Keep and Which do I Loose...

[Emme]

We are me, dh and ds (20) on the DDP and staying at POFQ and basically can't choose and pick excatly what we want. We are firm on Kona and O'Hanas but iffy about the rest. Please Help!! We are good eaters, fun loving, and are carnivores...lol. Please choose 3 (or 2 if you choose Narcoossees.) Pick and prioritize for me PLEASE!!

Chef Mickeys Breakfast
Crystal Palace Lunch
Boatwrights
Narcoossees
Tony's for dinner
Tutto Italia
Grand Floridian Cafe


Thanks so much!!

 

[DISNEYNV]

I will have to say Narcoosses! Great food and upscale atmosphere
Crystal Palace - great food for a buffet
Or
Tutto italia - planned for our May trip heard great things

What about Hollywood Brown Derby at HS or The Wave at the Contemporary? Not to throw in more choices but they were both excellent. Me Cellier as well!

 

[septbaby]

We are firm on Kona and O'Hanas but iffy about the rest. Please Help!! We are good eaters, fun loving, and are carnivores...lol. Please choose 2 if you choose Narcoossees.
Chef Mickeys Breakfast
Crystal Palace Lunch
Boatwrights
Narcoossees
Tony's for dinner
Tutto Italia
Grand Floridian Cafe


Thanks so much!!

Best meal experience and wonderful food at Narcoossee's. Excellent food and outrageous fun at Chef Mickey's.

 

[ElizabethB]

Cancel Tony's for dinner. Very poor when we were there a few months ago.

 

[Emme]

Anyone else please?

 

[septbaby]

Cancel Tony's for dinner. Very poor when we were there a few months ago.

Never been here, but it seems people perfer it for lunch?

 

[KatMark]

MickeyNicki just came back from Tony's and did a live review--said it was very good. Personally, I would drop Boatwright's. We went there September 07 for the last meal of our trip and it was by far the second worse meal and service we have ever had at Disney (following H&V and WCC would fall right after Boatwright's).

 

[Hopefully]

It appears from your signature that you are going in 8 days. I would call Disney Dining and see what is still available. You may find that your choices are very limited at this late stage.
I would not do Boatwright's or Tony's.
I ate at Narcoosee's years ago and enjoyed if very much, I would definitely go again.
Have a Great Trip

 

[Emme]

It appears from your signature that you are going in 8 days. I would call Disney Dining and see what is still available. You may find that your choices are very limited at this late stage.
I would not do Boatwright's or Tony's.
I ate at Narcoosee's years ago and enjoyed if very much, I would definitely go again.
Have a Great Trip

Nope all good~ I have ADR for all but Boatwrights and Grand Floridian Cafe...

 

[septbaby]

Are you staying at POR? Is that why you have Boatwright's on the list? Was there a specific item that drew your attention? Keep in mind they've stopped serving breakfast there.

GFC serves all three meals so you should be able to score that ADR if you decide you want to do that. Place seems to get pretty good reviews and is often described as "pretty, light", sounds like a nice place for a meal.

 

[Emme]

Are you staying at POR? Is that why you have Boatwright's on the list? Was there a specific item that drew your attention? Keep in mind they've stopped serving breakfast there.

Yes, we are at POFQ. I thought the filet on the dinner menu looked yummy and the angel food with banana foster sauce

 

[disneygirlinnj]

Tony's is defintiely better for lunch, IMO. Probably the best you'll get at the MK. As for the others? Narcossees and Tutto DEFINITELY. LOVED TUTTO!

 

[mrsannb]

My parents ate at Boatwrights when we visited in November because my dad wasn't feeling well enough to go anywhere else and they enjoyed it a lot.
I haven't been to most the places on your list, so I'm not sure. I have read several good reviews for Grand Floridian Cafe lately, and lots of people have recommended Chef Mickeys to us.