Which David is Getting Your Vote !?

[disney100666]

David Cook
orrrr
David Archuleta
on American Idol ?

BTW, Jonas Brothers are preforming "S.O.S" on the finale show, haha, they just posted a bulliten on myspace about it. ;]

 

[Ms.Squeakers]

Archuletta heres why :

Not many american idols get a good recording deal, they are just sold off as "American Idol!' and thats it. Then they dont get much attention, and dont sell that many records. This way cook can get second and get a better recording deal, and have a better shot of a career, without "AMERICAN IDOL" junk/publicity pulling them down.

BUT

Personally Im tired of Archuletta.

Cook is amazing.

 

[hidmickey:myantidrug]

Without question Cook. I can't stand Archuletta.

 

[Cinderelli16]

Archuletta all the way baby
He's so good!!!!

 

[chisnpeke]

David Cook

 

[disney100666]

My vote is for Cook.

But good point Mouse !

 

[chisnpeke]

Archuletta heres why :

Not many american idols get a good recording deal, they are just sold off as "American Idol!' and thats it. Then they dont get much attention, and dont sell that many records. This way cook can get second and get a better recording deal, and have a better shot of a career, without "AMERICAN IDOL" junk/publicity pulling them down.

BUT

Personally Im tired of Archuletta.

Cook is amazing.

A $1 million recording contract sounds pretty good to me. That is what you get when you win.


The recording industry is not very good right now. 19 Entertainment, the label who signs the Idol artists, really only has the money to promote ONE album, and that's the winner's. Last year Blake Lewis came in second. He's sold like 300,000 copies of his album. The year before that Katharine McPhee came in second, she has not been very successful. The only standout person who has done well singing wise who didn't win is Chris Daughtry. Jennifer Hudson has an Oscar. Two VERY big exceptions.

So no, in the long run it's better to win. Idol stigma or not. The two most successful winners, Kelly and Carrie...I do not think of Idol immediately anymore when I hear their songs. I think of THEM as a recording artist. They have successfully gotten ride of the Idol label or stigma.

 

[Loves Disney]

I think they both have amazing voices. But in all honesty, I probably wouldn't buy a CD of David A. David Cook, however, I would. I love that rock sounding voice. I guess I'm just a fan of raw rocker vocals, lol.

 

[BandGeek911]

I've been back and forth between David A. and David C.
I think I'm voting for Cook.

 

[valeriesunshine]

Cook.

 

[theodorechipmunkluvr]

Cook and here is why:
Cook has not won any other competetions or had a recording contract, i know everyone says that all those other ppl are following the rules but i dont care they had there chance. . . Cook might have won a talent show as a child but that doesnt give him fame. . . also architleta hasnt really changed since the beggining, he stll basically only sing pop songs, while cook sang one of my fave songs from poto!=D =]

 

[crazytp93]

Syesha fan now voting for Cook.

 

[minniesBFF]

Cook all the way. Archuletta reminds me too much of Zac Efron.

 

[chisnpeke]

Cook all the way. Archuletta reminds me too much of Zac Efron.

Both of them are NOT my type at all. No offense to those who like them, Zac Efron is pretty cute, but I could never picture myself dating someone like that.

 

[MinnieMO]

JASON FAN ALLLL THE WAY

I ♥ Jason (I share a b-day with him ♥♥♥)

I'm not voting for ne one

 

[baby<3]

Archuleta because he has pure, raw vocal talent.


Cook is good too...he's just not as vocally talented in my opinion. He's a great rocker...but I just love that pure sound =)

 

[reminisce]

Archuletta heres why :

Not many american idols get a good recording deal, they are just sold off as "American Idol!' and thats it. Then they dont get much attention, and dont sell that many records. This way cook can get second and get a better recording deal, and have a better shot of a career, without "AMERICAN IDOL" junk/publicity pulling them down.

BUT

Personally Im tired of Archuletta.

Cook is amazing.

ita. thats exactly my logic

 

[disneydance]

I dont watch the show anymore it got too boring for me so good luck to both contestants

 

[diva122094]

I think that David Arculata should win because if he does'nt he might not get famous.But if David Cook doesn't win he will probably become someone like Chris Daughtry.David Cook doesn't really need American Idol to become famous.

 

[OneTreeHill]

As much as I like Archuleta, I am voting Cook.
Archuleta is getting old.