Wow! I would never ever ever even if it was free (and I did turn down free passes for my family of 5) fly on ATA again. I am shocked to hear that so many have been happy with them. A friend of mine has flown them twice and hates them as much as I do. Seemed like everyone on the flights we were on who had flown them in the past didn't like them at all (WHY they were flying them again, I do not know!)
Hmmm, do you all have direct flights with them? Maybe, maybe, that would help.