Exactly.
Also I've considered a rain jacket because then I could also toss it on in restaurants if the AC is making me cold but I like that the poncho keeps my shorts and legs down to my knees dry plus it can help to keep my socks and shoes dry too if I'm just standing in one place.
Or with the rain jacket do you find it still keeps your shorts dry?
What rain jacket do you have if you don't mind sharing?
I'm not exactly anti other options because in that respect I say do what works for you but I am pro poncho since it works for me lol.
Oh and are they just as packable as a poncho?
I've only used rain jackets for the last 10-15 years. It's something I can use again at home, and don't fill up landfills with a bunch of useless single use plastic. The coverage isn't always as good as a poncho, IE I can't put my backpack/messenger bag under the rain jacket, but if it's raining that hard, I'm not going to be dancing around in the rain anyway. Most of the 2.5 layer options from Patagonia, REI, Marmot etc can be had for under $120, much less if you buy last years colors on sale. Spacewise they take up just about the same amount of room, probably a little less due to less material. But my rain jacket typically gets used all 4 seasons. With the right layers it serves well against rain, wind, snow etc and can be worn any day back in the real world. Personally I've used the Patagonia Torrentshell and Marmot Precip in the past, my current choice is one from L.L. Bean that seems to be discontinued. I've found most of them to be similar in performance, just comes down to different cuts and pocket configurations.