IMO, yes (although of course it's possible that I've received handmade invitations that I had no idea were handmade because they did look professional). I've gotten a couple DIY invitations that, to be honest, looked like elementary school craft projects. It didn't bother me as much as make me feel sorry for the bride - the invitation is one of the few parts of a wedding that lasts, because you'll keep one the rest of your life. I could imagine the girl looking at the thing in 25 years and thinking, "why on earth did I think I should glue a couple pieces of colored paper together and call it a wedding invitation?!" Keep in mind that making your own invites is also VERY timeconsuming - a friend of mine made her own with 2 bridesmaids, and it took them FOREVER.
OMG, I wasn't thinking handmade! I was thinking they could be made on the computer with heavy cardstock or something. Honestly I just didn't know if it could even be done.
We made DD's at home with a DIY kit from Michaels. They have tons to choose from...some look cheaper, others look nicer. My dd's were just beautiful and we had lots of compliments on them. We used the 40% off coupons on each box. Bought 5 boxes of 30 and spent right at $100. They included everything you would need including a template, resoponse cards, etc. We had a great time making them.
We also bought our programs there with the coupons. We got 150 programs for $15 and printed them ourselves

We also found lots of great ideas on Etsy, and my DH, DD and I made so many of these things for so much cheaper.
For our DD4 (flower girl) we saw a wooden box flower girl box that had a grapevine wreath handle. Bought the supplies at Michaels/AC Moore and made the $45 Etsy flower girl box for $10.
Here is a link to the Etsy one (I dont have a pic of ours uploaded, but it is the exact same)
http://www.etsy.com/listing/9582458...in=0&ga_max=0&ga_ref=auto1&ga_search_type=all
Just realize that there are so many things you can do, that you wouldnt think you could and that will save you lots!