My mom was highly opposed to the values ever since they opened, she was a total disney value snob

and refused to stay there. In 2002, she booked ASmo, but a month before our trip... upgraded to the CBR.
In 2007, we had our first ever stay at Pop Century. Boy were we surprised! I think she was already on cloud 9 because she wasn't paying for the trip (have to love men

) but she kept raving about how the values were above and beyond what she had read in past years.
Surprise 1) Room
People said it was so small... but we didn't find that to be the case at all. Yes.. it is a tight fit for a family, but any room is going to feel that way compared to home. We were able to sleep 3 people (1 in a pack and play) comfortably and the room still felt pretty spacious. It's no villa, but was plenty for our needs. We enjoyed the decor as well... not as "tacky" as we were expecting it to be. We had perfect housekeeping... including towel animals! For the time you really spend there... what else could you need?
Surprise 2) Transportation
Never once did we have an issue with Disney transportation. ME dropped us off first and picked us up last. I don't think I waited more than 10mins for a bus, and while lines at park closing were long, there was always a bus loading and sometimes 2 at a time.
Surprise 3) The "type of people"
For some reason... people just assume those who stay at values are "lower class" families, with rude, obnoxious behavior

I did it at one time too... I will admit it. We never experienced any of this behavior! It gets tough when you cram that many people into that small of a space... but we really enjoyed our fellow resort guests; no rowdy neighbors, no rude drunks, and no cursing teens. The kids scream just as loud as they do at the Grand Floridian...
Overall, our trip really opened our eyes to the value resorts and we finally accepted them. I wasn't overly happy with Pop (just too big for the space) and am looking forward to my stay at ASmu this Sept. Either way... values are now a-ok in my book.
As other posters have said... still looking forward to a stay at the WL, YC, or CR... but those are reserved for special occassions at the moment. I truly can't justify spending that much money on a room for the time we would really spend there.