From the post two posts above yours...
Cast Member also said that the area blocked off for VIP access would become smaller the closer parade time came based upon the number of VIP families showing up at the station for their priority section. If only a few came the area for the "common folk" would be increased. The entire station is not roped off just the area under the roof section so you can still go up there to watch you just don't have a place in the center.
Okay, that's what I thought. I never expected to get dead center spots anyway, as I knew there was a very good chance that other guests would beat me there even if it was *all* open. But from the way everyone was reacting, it started sounding like the entire area had been taken away.
I have no problem with Disney offering special packages, which naturally have to include some special perks, as long as they're not taking away *huge* swaths of experiences from everyone else. Having to stand an extra 10 yards to one side is not at all a big deal to me.
Some people value their time / having a "perfect" view enough to pay extra to save a spot are making a valid decision for themselves. That's worth it to some people. And for other people, they'd rather spend extra time saving a spot or taking a second row spot instead of the front. Also a valid choice.
As long as everyone who wants to see the parade can still manage to see it somewhere, with plenty of good spots available if you arrive early (and right now, that's definitely still the case), I think Disney is justified in offering a couple small, prime viewing areas, the same way any other entertainment venue does (box seats at a theater, 50-yd-line seats at a football game, etc.)
There's give and take in every decision we make, not just at Disney. For the parade, you can't get a perfect spot at the last minute for free - you have to decide which of those three you are willing to sacrifice. Previously, there was no choice - you just had to arrive early, and if you were on a tight schedule or you were solo and had to use he restroom or you had another reason you couldn't / didn't want to stay still in one place for an extra hour, there was no other way to get a good view - now there's another option, for those who decide to use their money that way.
Those are my thoughts on it. Anyway, I'm definitely still looking forward to my 2nd floor, slightly off-center, arrived-early-to-save-my-place parade viewing for my birthday.