the offsite and onsite debate will always go on. there are TOO MANY variables involved. how many days are you wanting to stay. is it just 2 adults OR a huge family. etc...etc. it's too hard to compare because every family is different in size and wants/needs.
as for me. i have no kids, just me and DGF. it's easier for us to stay onsite. i don't want to stay in a offsite "condo" because i live in one and that's the last place i want to be. i'm on vacation. i don't want to be anywhere that reminds me of home/work/etc.
but like i said...every disney guest has different wants and needs. apples to bananas.
This is so true. For me a condo rental is just a ridiculous amount of space...just me and dd19. We go Value Room, 40% discount (I only go w/ discount) which comes to about $55 per night and I think $65 weekend rate.
So for my 15 day trip in January the total room cost was $839.62
Park Tickets: $285 x 2 = $570
We don't eat alot, our food budget is $35 for the both of us per day (2 cs split and some snacks).
We don't really eat big breakfasts, we usually split a bagel, from home.
TS meals about $125, if any.
At a condo the meals wouldn't work b/c we go open to close. We'd be starving by the time we got back to the room to cook....and to me it would be a hassle leaving the park mid-day and coming back. But I also no longer have young kids that would melt down and need a rest. Our vacations are go go go...fun fun fun...adventure, I can relax when I'm 6 feet under
My worst bit of advice was not from DIS but a friend who suggested we get the earliest flight so we could have an extra day in the park (arrival day). Well, I didn't quite factor in having to leave for the airport at 3am to allow for all check in and 45 min to the airport. We were so tired we just went to DTD, which is what I would have done normally!