Well, as it turns out I believe I had a combination of things go wrong with my attempt at reservations. First, I was searching for our whole group, which is 9. It appears as though the restaurants involved don't have tables for 9, so they show as "no available times". Which is odd, because why would that number even be available in the drop down for party size, if its not available at all.
Then, part 2 is that I got a rookie CM when I called dining. She said that there were no times available that day either. Then silence. I said, "so, did I need to be on the phone around midnight or something?". Silence. I said, "any recommendations? should i just keep checking for cancellations?" Yes, she said. Okay, then. Thanks.
So, I kept trying different things all day long. I tried different party sizes, and tried all of the different restaurant options. Eventually, later in the afternoon I
was able to get a party of 5 reservation for the River Belle Terrace. Blue Bayou still showed sold out. So I called dining back - new CM, much cheerier and more knowledgeable. He informed me that Blue Bayou has no tables big enough (again, why have the number in the drop down then?), and that if I make two reservations, I have to make them in separate names, but that the restaurant will honor both then, and try to sit us close together.
I made a second reservation for 4 at the same time (3:50 pm, only thing available). Thus, I have reservations for all 9 of us. Yay!
I think part of the problem is that this is the Friday before Dapper Day? Maybe that's why they're selling those shows out quicker.
Here's a question. They have 2 shows that night. With a 3:50 reservation, will we be seated for the earlier show? (I hope so!)
Thanks!