We only stay at Deluxe resorts and villas, so here's my personal preference for these (we've stayed at them all several times).
1. Grand Floridian/Villas
2. Contemporary/BLT
3. Yacht Club
4. Beach Club/Villas
5. Saratoga Springs
6. Polynesian/Villas
7. Boardwalk/Villas
8. Old Key West
9. Riviera
10. Wilderness Lodge/Villas
11. Animal Kingdom/Villas