3DisneyKids said:
You are right by making this a well thought-out decision. DVC should not be an impulse buy. Ask every question that pops into your head...folks here are more knowledgeable in most cases than your guide or even MS.
I totally agree! I backed out of our first DVC contract with Disney within the 10 day period last year because I got cold feet. It is a major decision. After reading these boards and doing a lot of analysis, I felt comfortable enough to buy DVC this year.
All the points about use year, number of points and location of your home resort are very important. The mantra heard often on these boards is "Buy where you want to stay." If you have your heart set on one particular resort keep that in mind with the 11 month home resort booking advantage. After 7 months, all the resorts can be reserved if they have availability. For key times like the Food and Wine Festival in the Fall, the Epcot-based DVCs will be harder to book if they are not your home resort.
If you think of a question, do a search, it probably was asked before. If you can't find the answer, feel free to start a thread and people will help.
You are right to question everything because this is a big decision. For some, it works for them. For others, they choose not to buy either for personal financial reasons, pattern and frequency of travel to Disney, etc. Many on these boards feel that you get the most economic use out of your points if you use your DVC points for the DVC properties and pay cash for the extras such as the cruises, Grand Floridian, etc.
For my family, DVC makes sense for us. Too many nights sharing a values room in a double bed with the TV on mute so the little ones can sleep!
Good luck with your decision.