Late to this party...as usual...lol...
We have several must-do places. Not my choice, but my very regimented family's choice. They, 1 DH and 3 older kids, have their places they just have to eat at EVERY.TRIP. Ohana, Biergarten, Beaches and Cream, Yak and Yeti and Sanaa are some.
Next tier would be Cape May, Liberty Tree Tavern, Boma.
Then I like to mix in new places every trip but end up getting just 1 or 2, due to the above (must-do regulars).
But we too have been so many times, as
DVC, we now kind of 'wing it'. I'll make ADRs for a few places, specifically the tough to get places and then we will change and cancel plans or just walk in or hit the
MDE app and see what's available. I prefer the 'wing-it' style of vacationing.
Also, now that we are older and the kids may not be with us (either on the trip or at meals), DH and I are starting to try the signatures. He poo-poo'd them all the years of the kids being little. When we first started going to WDW, we'd get the DP and do 1 signature and pay out of pocket for 1 dinner. And then DH preferred the dinner shows as our signature due to them including adult beverages. So I only recently went to Cali Grill for the first time and it was to die for. We are going again in Oct. We have Jiko, AP and CG booked for Oct and plan to also go to Tiffins. And DH has mentioned Shula's too. Looking forward to it.