
Here are a few that have been used by our family/friends recently.
Anna
Carley
Kate
Ellen
Sophie
Leah
Paige
Ava
Here are some older family names that I considered:
Elaine
Susan
Gail
Debra
Rose
Ryan (yep, I thought about this for a girl)
Wow! I am so overwhelmed with all your suggestions. We really like Annabelle. I have always loved belle or bella on the end of names, but never thought of another option besides Isabelle or Isabella.
We also like Alexa and one other which I want to keep a secret. Thanks to everyone for all their responses!!!

If you think Emma is popular...ANYTHING with Belle or Bella is really, really popular! Someone just mentioned Leah. I have a niece by that name. I think Leah goes really well with Emma. I think both girls names should have equal "weight". They have a similar 'feel" to me. I think one of the other gals in my family has a much more elegant/formal name than what I was given.
This makes me a little sad DH and I picked Annabelle because it was not a Top 100. We did not want a top 100 name. I will just have to hope for the best because there is no changing it now... We already love it and it is on a lot of what we have for her.
Don't be sad. Annabelle is a BEAUTIFUL name! We actually considered it for our now DS6 had he been a girl. I don't think Annibelle itself will be top 100--just that LOTS of little girls are being called Bella or Belle right now because of Isabelle, Isabella, etc...
Thank you tho for making me feel better about the situation.