Sorry, I have always liked the "Welcome Home". I'm in the group who feels it has been watered down by using it for everyone.
Just my opinion, but many Members here seem to be evaluating their membership solely on tangible stuff. They seem to be calculating that if they save $3.42 by being a
DVC Member, they will feel special.
That's fine if that's what makes them happy.
For my wife and me, we like the "feel good stuff" just as much if not more than the tangible. It's just not all about saving a few bucks on park tickets for us. There is definitely an emotional side about everything Disney. In my opinion, the whole idea of WDW plays on one's emotions.
Over the years I've read many complaining about wasted money. Many here have complained about the expensive publications, mailings, special items (think giclee), letterhead for reservations, and on and on...
You see, at least for us, that's what makes DVC and Disney special. Yes, we feel special. If some think that's "elitist", than so be it.
-- That's just one Member's opinion.
MG