You say you have rented points in the past and enjoyed your vacations so you should be familiar with a
DVC resort. Are you more worried about the cons such as maint. fees? That was one of my concerns, but when I figured out what a year of DVC costs versus what I would spend on other accomadations, it became clear that DVC was the way to go. Should the time come we decide to end our membership, it should still retain a good resale value and I hope to recapture most (if not all) of our purchase price.
Otherwise some of the pros you have probably already experieced when you rented are:
1. Bigger rooms than a normal resort.
2. Kitchens to help lower our food costs for a family of 6.
3. Being 'on property' and enjoying the benefits of such.
4. A variety of themed resorts for us to choose from for our stay.
5. The fact we are forced to take a vacation or else loose points. Work no longer gets in the way.
6. Being able to use our timeshare when we want, within the points we have.
7. Having more relaxed vacations and not having the feeling that we need to do the parks commando style or all day long.
8. With the bigger rooms, you can relax more than you could in a standard motel room.
9. Just love being "home".