WDW vs DL

StephPlum

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 1, 2011
Messages
2,047
I just had my first trip to WDW this September. I never thought I would say it but I am a Disney convert now. Been back for two weeks and trying to plan the next trip!

I take a trip once a year to an industry conference. This year it was in Orlando, hence the trip to WDW. I try to tack on a vacation on the end of these conferences (Grand Canyon, New York, Boston...). Next September the conference is in LA. So I am thinking I should stay a few days and go DL.

Will I enjoy DL if I liked WDW? Looks like some of the rides are the same. Is September a good time to go? How are the crowds?

TIA for any help.
 
When it comes to the great debate "WDW vs DL," I have to say it's like the way I look at my kids. I love them both, and they fill my life with joy in their own unique way.

Growing up in Alabama, my family always vacationed at WDW, so that was all I knew. Disney was a monorail hotel, park hoppers, bus rides, totally immersed in Disney for a week. Fast forward to my marriage to a guy from Southern California coupled with living in Utah and California, I had to adjust to "the smaller castle."

I've always loved my trips to Disneyland. They just weren't the all-inclusive trips I was used to. We normally stay at his parents and go spend the day at the park, go home, and return a few days later. Lather. Rinse. Repeat. I did get to a point, admittedly, where going to Disneyland really seemed to get on my nerves. It seemed to get more and more crowded with each visit, and I didn't enjoy the company of other guests. They just seemed uptight and rude. So, this June we went as a family back to my roots at Disney World.

It was a fantastic trip!!! We stayed at the Polynesian and watched fireworks from the beach. We did Star Wars Weekends. We rode the Figment ride a million times--everything I missed so much. The weather was great as were the people we met. But after a long flight with two small kids and a whirlwind adventure, I sure was tired when we got home. I think it took 3 weeks to really get back on my game. It was then, I realized, Disneyland sure is nice in that regard. Fast forward to a few weeks ago and a return trip to Disneyland.

We stayed at my in-laws whose home which is as nice as any hotel I've ever stayed at. We went in September (perfect weather and manageable crowd--average 20 minute wait which doesn't bother me), and I was determined to go with fresh eyes and a positive attitude. I didn't want to compare DL to WDW; instead, I decided we would do what we couldn't do in Orlando. We rode Casey Junior, took the serene journey through Storybookland, and had a Haunted Mansion Holiday. I met fantastic people who were very forgiving of my tantruming toddler. The cast members were genuine in their enthusiasm. It was just as fun as Florida, and at the end of the evening, I looked at the light in Walt's window above the firehouse and uttered a quiet, "Thanks, Walt." Because either way, in either park, the magic lives on.

You'll find it if you look for it regardless of the size of the castle or the temperature in the air. The magic permeates throughout at Disneyland just as much as in Florida. Like with my kids, they are very different, but at the end of the day I love them both because they are mine.

Happy travels!

ETA: I hope I didn't sound preachy. I was just sharing my personal experience as a bona fide WDW loyalist. Try Disneyland. It's great, and September is my new favorite time to go.
 
We just got back from our first trip to WDW and although we had a lot of fun and really enjoyed it, we love Disneyland so much more.
 
I went to Disneyland twice as a child and WDW once. Then, I hadn't been back for 20 years. In 2010, we went to WDW for a week, LOVED it! Went to Disneyland for 4 days this year - and upgraded to APs! We love them both and I bet you will, too!
 

I just had my first trip to WDW this September. I never thought I would say it but I am a Disney convert now. Been back for two weeks and trying to plan the next trip!

I take a trip once a year to an industry conference. This year it was in Orlando, hence the trip to WDW. I try to tack on a vacation on the end of these conferences (Grand Canyon, New York, Boston...). Next September the conference is in LA. So I am thinking I should stay a few days and go DL.

Will I enjoy DL if I liked WDW? Looks like some of the rides are the same. Is September a good time to go? How are the crowds?

TIA for any help.
After Labor Day crowds drop off and refurbs increase significantly. That works for some people and not for others.

This might be a good place to start...

"A DLR Guide for WDW Vets" www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=1162599
 
Thanks for the replies. I had skimmed the DLR guide before (very detailed) and was used in my thinking that I wanted to try DLR since I would be in LA anyway.

Didn't realize about the rehabs. I'll probably wait until closer to see what is going to be closed before making a firm decision.
 
Thanks for the replies. I had skimmed the DLR guide before (very detailed) and was used in my thinking that I wanted to try DLR since I would be in LA anyway.

Didn't realize about the rehabs. I'll probably wait until closer to see what is going to be closed before making a firm decision.

Rehabs at DLR and WDW are the same. Done during slow periods. So nothing lost or gained at one resort or the other if timing of visits is the same.

But one caveat. In DL Haunted Mansion closes Late August through mid September for a special overlay that it gets for Christmas and Halloween. Also Space Mountain closes for a few days in the second week for a Halloween overlay.

So keep those two things in mind, and also that the official DLR calendar will show you the rehabs only 60 days out, so that may tighten up the planning period for you.
 
I just had my first trip to WDW this September. I never thought I would say it but I am a Disney convert now. Been back for two weeks and trying to plan the next trip!

I take a trip once a year to an industry conference. This year it was in Orlando, hence the trip to WDW. I try to tack on a vacation on the end of these conferences (Grand Canyon, New York, Boston...). Next September the conference is in LA. So I am thinking I should stay a few days and go DL.

Will I enjoy DL if I liked WDW? Looks like some of the rides are the same. Is September a good time to go? How are the crowds?

TIA for any help.

If you set up WDW as an ideal and anything that departs from that as less tha ideal, you probably won't like DLR. If you judge DLR on its own merits you will have a great time. Of the rides that are the same name, many are different and better at DLR.
Some of the rides are similar, but have different names. Indiana Jones is similar to Dinosaur. But the theming is much better. Grizzly river Run is a circular raft ride like Kali. But it's much better.
Oh and did I mention THE SUBS!!!! WOOOHOOOO!!!!!
 

New Posts



Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom