You don't need a car to get around, we just find it faster and more convenient, and we like to go off site alot. We have visited at least a couple of dozen times, so we are never in a rush. If this is your 1st time you may not want to use so much time in transport. Is this for lunch or dinner? What time will you be getting in? How many hours will you have traveled? What time did you have to get up? Are you going into the parks this day? These are all questions which would impact my desire to travel to another hotel for a meal. I usually allow 1 hour to get from one Disney location to another when using their transport. As far as menu choices go, I don't think you can go wrong with either. If you are going for lunch, Chef Mickey's will be closed, this may be a good thing as you can see and hear alot of the goings on at dinner time, and the girls may be dissappointed that they will not be able to participate, Concourse is right next door with just a low divider to seperate them.