Last summer we went to the Luau at RPR , like was said, food was good and plenty of it, same with the drink, but the Mai Tai`s where pretty weak so just drank the beer.As for the show it was a typical luau, hula dancers fire juggling and getting people up on stage ,it was ok but would not go again as i have seen it.
We went to the Poly at disney the year before, food was good as well and plenty of attention from the service staff so drink was flowing. The Disney one was more of a story along the lines of a girl who had left the island and came back, it was ok but would not rush to go back either.
They where 2 completly different shows, and i had read different reports about them , but decided to go and decide for myself. I am glad i did them. Just to say my DD 11 loved both of them, she even went to the RPR one a few nights later with a friend she met as they had it booked and asked if she would like to go