We just returned from a 5 night stay at the Dolphin. Loved it! Would stay there again in a heartbeat. Some random info from our stay
We were on 9th floor with a balcony overlooking the resort - just a few rooms from the elevators. There was some construction going on on floor 9 in the other wing. We saw them but never heard them, even on our sleep in day. Our room (not yet renovated) was just fine. No issues with the room, beds, bathroom or balcony. Beds were super comfortable. The rollaway was also not an issue - there was plenty of room for it in the corner by the balcony door. We've traveled as a family of 5 many times and had no problems with privacy or personal space. The balcony helped a lot in that regard - making the room seem bigger and giving a space to get away from everyone if needed. We had originally planned to use an air mattress for my nephew since we were already paying the 5th person charge of $25/night we didn't want to also pay the $25/night rollaway charge. When checking in the bellman offered to get us the rollaway at no charge. In the end we weren't charged for either of these things. On check out, the only charges we had were the resort fees (the room was paid for with SPG points).
Housekeeping - the first morning I ran back up to the room after breakfast (about 830am) and our room was already cleaned!!!! Wow. Unfortunately, that was the only day they cleaned our room before 3pm. Once day she came and knocked at 4 and we were showering and getting ready to head back out so the night crew came in while we were at dinner. I will say though that the woman who was assigned to our room during the day was super nice and helpful when she saw us return and hadn't done our room yet she hurried over with clean towels and offers to get us anything we needed. When they did clean, they did a great job, no complaints. All in all, we were happy with the housekeeping services.
Restaurants - We ate at Fresh the first morning. Overpriced is the word the comes to mind. Most of the group had the buffet. My mistake, I confused Picabu and Fresh and by the time we realized it we were already seated and drinking our coffee... Picabu was great for a quick bite or a late night snack. The pizza was not bad - no slices so we had to get the whole pie. Much better than the hockey rink quality pizza served at the place on the Boardwalk. We spent most of our time in the parks so didn't have a chance to try any of the other restaurants.
Pools - For December we had Spring type weather with 80s during the day and 60s at night. The kids swam just about every day, the pools were warm and they enjoyed going from one pool to the next. We adults used the hot tubs. The pools were pretty empty, especially at night. 9pm is a bit early to close a pool at a resort but it was helpful in getting the kids back up to the room.
Transportation - We rented a mini van from National @ MCO and returned it using the National service at the hotel. Dropped it off with the valet on check in. Easy as pie, cheaper than a shuttle or car service for 5 people and we had control of our stops for snacks, water and sunblock plus a quick lunch along the way. Also no parking charge while we were there. We did the same for our return. I picked up the keys from the National desk in the lobby and the valet brought it around and loaded it up. Drove it straight to the airport and dropped it off after dropping family and bags at the curb. Total cost of both 1 day/1 way mini van rentals was $108.
We took the bus to MK the afternoon of our arrival. It took about 20 minutes including the wait for the bus. DHS we took the boat both ways on Friday. No issues going over in the morning about 9:00 but coming back at 8pm was at least a 40 minute wait for a boat. We didn't make the cut off for the first full boat then 2 boats came and dropped off but didn't pick anyone up!!! Lots of boos from the 150+ people in the boat queue. I really felt bad for the ones who didn't make it onto the boat that finally came as their wait was easily over an hour. EPCOT we were tired so took the boat over and then walked back. It's interesting how the CMs try to convince you to walk instead of taking the boat ride because it's "at least 15 minutes longer". For us, it was a nice 15 minute rest. For our return that night we walked both ways due to a long line at the boat dock and a big crowd after the fireworks. AK we had an early breakfast ADR so we called to the valet for a taxi/car. It was waiting when we got downstairs and was about $20 + tip. Worth it. On the way home from AK, two of us took the bus and the other 3 went on a 2nd safari ride and then took a taxi. They arrived less than 1/2 hour after we did. Wilderness lodge for our dinner ADR we took a taxi to the lodge (again about $20 + tip and very quick) then the boat to MK after dinner. Waited about 20 minutes for the boat to arrive. There was quite a big line waiting by the time it arrived and not everyone fit so some were left to wait even longer for the next one.. Took the bus back to the Dolphin from MK 2 late nights (12am Christmas party and 12am regular park close) and both times the bus was pretty painless. One night it stopped at the Swan first and the other it stopped at the Dolphin first. Not sure why the different route.
All in all, we had a great trip and really enjoyed the Dolphin. The location was stellar and every single person we dealt with was pleasant and friendly and helpful. If I can answer any questions, just let me know.