Via Napoli, Tutto Italia, or Mama Melrose?

[kstorms27]

Which place has the better italian food, Via Napoli, Tutto Italia, or Mama Melrose? If none of them, then where on WDW property is the best place for italian food? Looking specificly for dinner. Thx!

 

[chinarider]

Sorry cant really help with any info but, I do have ADR's at all 3 for our trip in May ( we're there 10 days, what can I say, we like Italian ).

 

[vettegirl]

Tutto Italia is fantastic. Both meals I have eaten there have been incredible and the interior of the restaurant is upscale and very nice.

Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards

 

[Figee17]

Of the three of those, we like Via Napoli the most, although we've only had the pizza there, it was delish!

We actually prefer to head over to the Swan to Il Mulino for an Italian meal. They are also great about customizing dishes there, for some of my more picky family members

 

[marshallsmommy]

We have been to all three and I would say all were good in some respects but the winner for us was Tutto everything was amazing, but if you are looking for pizza nothing beats Via Napoli!

 

[SGMCO]

I love Tutto!! We eaten there several times and it has always been very good. I also like Via Naples for the wood fired pizzas, very good.

 

[wiigirl]

Tutto Italia is fantastic. Both meals I have eaten there have been incredible and the interior of the restaurant is upscale and very nice.

Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards

 

[Smiling Cheshire Cat]

I've eaten at all 3 and like Tutto's the most. We like Via Napoli too, but it seems to specialize more in pizza. We didn't like Mama Melrose's.

 

[shadeauxe]

I will second the vote for Il Mulino. It was fantastic.

I've never eaten at Tutto Italia, but I did not like Via Napoli. I ordered a veggie white lasagna (I think) and it was not that great.

 

[ettinkerbell]

Il Mulino's at the Swan - simply wonderful, authentic Italian cuisine

 

[DisKH]

Never don Il Muno but out of the other two I would hands-down go for Via Napoli! I love their pizza, their lasagna and their desserts are excellent!

 

[jacobmommy]

Great question, interested in other's opinions as well.

We have eaten at Tutto Italia and were not really impressed. I don't consider the family to be picky, but we had trouble finding something we wanted there.

 

[stormtracker]

We've done all three. Tutto and Via Napoli are both very good. If anyone wants pizza Via Napoli is your best bet. Mama Melrose is good, just not as good as the others.