You really ought to try it yourself and not be overly influenced by a single review. FWIW I have pretty much the opposite feel about BLT and / or feel that the negatives expressed here apply in some way or other across the board to
DVC resorts or to MK resorts. The dining at CR is no further away than from virtually every other DVC and other than the short outdoor walkway its all indoor access. Not all rooms have the maintenance issues that OP had. I've not had anything similar at BLT but have at other resorts - that's just a factor of rooms getting varying wear and tear and needing attention at various times.
The BLT decor is modern but that is simply a matter of taste. Nothing to dispute on the size of the studios. It's well discussed how small they are but I like the new layout since the moved the bathroom sink. There's a difference on brightness depending on where in the building your room is located but the decor is light and I haven't found it as dark as other resorts. Transportation at all deluxe resorts is little to brag about but at least you have access to one park that you know will always be fast - walking to/from the MK.
Just another opinion. And I just had a 5 night stay with an old college friend in a BLT studio in Nov. She gave a bite thumbs up to the resort and we had a great time.
To the original poster... My wife and I just stayed at BLT, also during the first week of December here's our take on our experience..
Background: just purchased 210pts @ BWV a couple of months ago. Thanks to the folks on this board, you saved us alot of money. we originally purchased 160pts at VGF at $155pt. then we cancelled after some knowledgeable folks here pointed us in the right direction!!
We have been visiting the parks for years (just turned 40) first with our two children, but now more so just the two of us with the kids coming down once a year.. We like to visit at least once during Christmas Time for the decor and Christmas Party. Unfortunately we were unable to book a studio at BWV due to the short notice but found three nights at BLT (1st night lake view, 2nd theme park view, 3rd lake view).
Day of arrival: We always rent a vehicle, even before when we stayed off property we found that having a vehicle frees up alot of time waiting around and marching off to a designated area to be picked up.. we utilized the buses in the past and wife just doesn't enjoy it, nor do i that much but could deal if needed to. So we arrive at about 1130am. park, check in and sure enough they have a room ready (7518), this is a theme park view which they arranged to have us stay in the first two nights and said they would work on the third as well.. only downside was a couple extra points for 2 other nights which we agreed to. Staff = Wonderful helpful people...
First night: We notice the TV would freeze up? called downstairs they said they would replace it, they did (we guess) but sure enough when we got back, it was still freezing on an image while the sound was progressing.. then it got to the point of one picture and no changing of channels? i unplugged it and began to work properly for an hour then again... OK call them back 11pm, they come up say they'll change it tomorrow... We go to sleep... somewhere around 330am or so i wake up due to a noise coming from the Clock radio... almost like Morse code, some type of interference.. fantastic.. too tired, just slept, woke up etc etc lol...
Next Morning: Wake up.. phone message light blinking... phone will NOT respond to retrieve messages lol starting to get annoyed now.. Wife yells from the shower there's no hot water.. Now i'm getting extremely annoyed

... So............. Maintenance comes up we leave for breakfast (she wasn't kidding about the hot water lol) the Wave fantastic service food was fine, enjoyable experience we've eaten here several times. Just a note, my wife did not enjoy the sparse christmas decorations but it is "contemporary" so i get it... The monorail is so convenient and we were on the 5th floor so the sky bridge was a 100' direct walk if that, no issue there. i could see if we stayed on a different floor probably would get monotonous.. Great day at parks (we hop, another car must have too make up time imo)
We return home and 1.No clock radio... it's just gone. 2. TV STILL giving us a problem, called down and they said it's the "satellite" there's nothing to be done (even though when you unplug the TV it works fine for a while lol) hot water now fixed.. So 1 out of 3 not too bad.. also my wife pointed out the table was stained and that the carpet looked pretty dingy. We loved the view of the castle from our room.. that was nice.. but what's with the plastic cutlery and bowls/plates??? weird... Is it different for a 1br?
We decided do to our love of all things disney we would try to stay another evening.. So when we were visiting BWV we inquired as to any availability.. they said SURE! if you want to pay cash.. I said, no thank you.. can we use our points? they said NOPE! this did not make me happy, but it is what it is.. So were travel home later on and i said you know the staff at BLT was so nice lets try to get another night here or somewhere else.. they made a call to the back office and sure enough they said they can accommodate us for another evening.. we were happy with the help, just not so happy about not trying another resort given the issues (more so with the wife) and me wanting to show her a great time. We explained to them that we own at BWV, it's our first trip etc etc, they were SHOCKED that BWV did not get us in for a night.. which i have to say surprised us... but again, i guess it's not what you know but "who you know"..
Also on the "studio" Disney is pretty cute with that term, it's an inch larger than a hotel room.. but that's OK, we're not in there much while down there.. on a longer vacation we will stay in a 1 or 2br..
Anyway, we are staying in a 1br at BWV in February for 5 days for our daughters birthday. I hope to report back with a great story.. We love Disney, we are retiring in 2028 and i plan on relocating us down there so we can enjoy it anytime we wish (going to move within an hour of the area).
In short: BLT scale of 1-10 gets a 6 from us.. Staff get a solid 10..
PS. we never did get our clock radio back lol