Ten short days later, I was back at Disney with my Gram!
We got a later start then we intended (surprise surprise) and didn't make it to Epcot for lunch as planned.
We arrived in just in time to unpack and settle in the room before heading to our 5:00 ADR at Yachtsman Steakhouse.
We checked in and had to wait about 5 minutes but we got to check out the meat aging room so we could start pondering what cut of steak to order!
We were seated at a two top table right near a room with beautiful bay windows looking out on to Stormalong Bay:
We both received menus that said "Happy Birthday'. We were perusing them as our server showed up to take drink orders. I briefly considered some wine, but knew I would drinking quite a lot of it in the coming days so I decided against it and just went with water. Gram had a seltzer with lime.
Gram took a look at kids menu, but they didn't have any actual steak on it, which she really wanted. So after a long time figuring out what to get we finally placed our order.
The server then brought out the bread basket, which has Pull-Apart Onion Rolls, Sourdough Rolls, and is served with Roasted Garlic, along with Butter and Sea Salt:
This might take the cake (the bread?) for the best bread basket at Disney. The Onion rolls were amazing! Warm, soft, fluffy, buttery but not too greasy, and had a nice subtle onion flavor. The sourdough rolls were perfect as well and just outstanding with a dab of butter and clove of the roasted garlic spread on them. I truly could have been happy with just the bread for dinner!

We finished our basket but resisted when we were offered a second one.
For a started, we split the
Steakhouse 'Wedge' Salad - organic greens, hen egg, heirloom apples, and tomatoes with sweet cream dressing.
I don't really see how this resembled a wedge salad...but it was tasty nonetheless. The greens were mild and sweet, and I loved how the julienned the apples. The tomatoes were ripe and tasty, and I liked the egg with it all. The dressing was subtle and let you taste the vegetables well.
For our entrees, Gram and I decided to split a few things. For our steak, we went with the
8oz Center Cut Filet Mignon, served with Mashed Potatoes and Cabernet Wine Sauce:
We ordered the filet medium rare, and it came out perfectly:
The steak was very good. I have really high standards for steak and this didn't disappoint. The meat was tender, flavorful, and not at all tough. I really think the aging is key for a better steak. This wasn't the best steak I've ever eaten (the honor repeatedly goes to Bern's Steakhouse in Tampa), but this was definitely up there and worth going back for.
I liked the wine sauce with the steak...if I didn't drink my wine, it was great to have it in my food!
The mashed potatoes were good, house made for sure. They were plain, but had good potato flavor, and it complemented the strong meat and sauce nicely.
We also got a side of
White Balsamic Caramelized Onions:
I actually didn't care for these. The balsamic vinegar kind of cancels out the sweetness of the caramelization. It wasn't bad....I just wasn't a fan and would prefer basic caramelized onions. My Grandma enjoyed them.
And
Truffle Mac n Cheese made with Orecchiette Pasta and Reypenaer Cheese:
This was REALLY good. I'm a sucker for truffle mac n cheese and this was a very well done version. The pasta was house-made, cooked perfectly al dente, and was a great choice of shape since the shallow cups held the cheese sauce well. There was a lot of cheese and very little filler of cream. The truffle flavor went great with the meal - earthy, aromatic, and a perfect dish for fall!
We were pretty full from all that heavy food, but we had to check out the dessert menu! I figured I would be ordering something because I can't pass up desserts at the signatures, but to my utter shock....nothing on the dessert menu appealed to me much.

So Gram and I decided we'd take a stroll around Crescent Lake and look for sweets somewhere else.
EDIT:
I forgot...we did have a dessert in Yachtsman!
Both Gram and I were given little complimentary cupcakes with lit candles for our birthdays! It was just a standard mini vanilla cupcake, nothing wonderful....but thoughtful and very much appreciated nonetheless! Our server even sang to us.
This was first visit to Yachtsman Steakhouse and I left fairly impressed. I read a lot of mixed reviews, but it turned out to be excellent for us. The cuisine isn't super creative, but something that's ok and not what one is looking for. It's a nice semi-upscale steak and potatoes place, and sometimes, that's just what you want.
I've now been to all of the
DDP signatures and I have a hard time ranking them because there are a lot of ties. Citricos still remains my absolute favorite. The only one I don't care for is Narcoossee's. Yachtsman will be added in to the rotation!
Grade for Yachstman: A