We have done 5 Thanksgivings at WDW. Call exactly 90 days out. The reservations fill up fast. This is what we have done.
1st - LTT - The food was their usual fare and nothing special was done for Thanksgiving. I will admit now that I am not a fan. For some reason the marinade on the steak makes me sick for days. But the real problem was going into MK on Thanksgiving day. We are lucky and spend the week there and Thanksgiving day is wall to wall people. We walked out of dinner into the pre-parade line up and I thought my husband who hates crowds was going to faint. You could not move without pushing past people's shoulders. Keep that in mind when you choose.
2nd year - The Polynesian Review - we had a great time but once was enough. We will have to go back sometime soon since they changed the show.
3rd year - Boma at AKL - (yes, we were doing a multicultural theme), It was great. I scheduled dinner for around 8 and we went early to look at the animals at sunset. Definitely a lot of fun.
4th year - Artist Point - we had never eaten there and really liked it . It was just fancy enough to make it seem special to me. The food was great.
5th year - Le Cellier in Canada - we are Creme Brule fans and we had heard about thier pumpkin creme brule the year before. They had a traditional Thanksgiving dinner. We had reservations at 7 pm and got the last 4 pumpkin creme brules so I will rethink my dessert strategy. Our server was fantastic.
My DD is now 17 and my DS will be 15 by Thanksgiving and we are considering the buffet at the Dolphin (from Deb Will's site). We can have a buffet dinner and 17 characters at a site next to BWV where we stay.
Maybe this will help in your decision
