Hummm....
OK... IMHO - in this order, and why:
1) The Contemporary - Club Level: My first love... the number one choice for me. They have never, and - in my mind - can never do wrong ! Had the opportunity to do a two-week stay, and it was like "family" - we never wanted to leave !

2) The Beach Club - Club Level: My ultimate "second-choice" in that it's in a "prime location" (walking distance or a short, boat-ride away to both EPCOT & DHS), great dining offerings (in-resort, the Cape May Cafe' and The Yachtman's Steakhouse) and outside the resort, but very close - the restaurants of The Swan & Dolphin, the restaurants of The Boardwalk Inn and area, and the restaurants of both EPCOT & DHS), the service, the accommodations, the decor and - last but certainly not least - the pool - are all an absolute delight !

3)If you are looking for something a little "out-of-the-way" you have The Wilderness Lodge Resort - Club Level, which also has a very nice pool area (and geyser !) and a very "rustic" appeal....

4) The Animal Kingdom Lodge - Club Level: Although I believe the location to be a "draw-back", I must admit that the resort amenities, the restaurants and the "views" are, at times, almost breathtaking.

5) The Grand Floridian Resort - Club Level: Simply stated - it is what it is...! You have noted that you have already stayed there (club level), so you know exactly what I am referring too ! And although you can't deny just how fantastic a stay at this resort can be... and just how much better it gets at "club-level", there is absolutely nothing that can match a "club-level" stay in the "Main Building" ! We did it once, for our "5th Anniversary" and, although it was expensive as h***, I'm glad that we did it... and it was certainly worth every penny !

(with two nights at "Victoria & Albert's, no less !

)
6) The Yacht Club Resort - Club Level: ...was really nice, and with a super-room-upgrade, was a delightful stay, but I found the colors and decor to be a drawback (How's that for whining ! Pretty sad when that what you have to complain about in life ! LOL !)

7) The Polynesian Resort - Club Lever: possibly some of the nicest CMs we've ever met; but, for some reason, it just isn't for me....
That's my list of Deluxe Resort - Club Level stays.... It makes me realize just how fortunate

and how spoiled

I've (we've) been ! Hope it helps.