OKW to be the only 'true' DVC resort.
Nobody but the one poster thinks its the only true resort, it's just some silly line they repeatedly post, they've never been able to explain it when asked. Let us know what your husband thinks and if he starts crying on his knees and has to try to add points on at OKW. He probably won't need OKW points to stay there unless you want a GV, there is more availability for OKW at the 7 month window than any other DVC resort. If he does want points, the resale prices are lower than for any other WDW onsite resort because of the reduced demand/desirability, the market pretty much tells the story. We were looking at OKW but didn't like how removed it was from everything, if your going to travel everywhere by bus (except DTD) and not have hotel like amenities, you might as well stay at an offsight timeshare and use thier bus transportation, there are some nice ones very near WDW, especially with some of the slow bus service at OKW that people have complained about in the past. There are some owners with OKW purchase regret, who wish they owned at another DVC resort instead of OKW, although if they got in early, they sure paid less, more power to them. And, there are many who love it, and have many nice things to say about it. To each his own. There are OKW members who wait for the 7 month window to get into BWV, which happens more requently than the other way around as demonstrated by the 7 month window availability.
You may not be aware, but there have been a few threads recently with banter back and forth regarding which resort is the best one, to the degree to which square footage was calculated and compared and disputed, and many folks have expressed why thier home resort is better than the ones other's have choosen, they are all wonderful places to stay, and I think your approach of trying each resort to see for yourself is a great idea, perhaps we should consider doing the same. We'd like to try WLV and BCV, they look like a great resorts, probably the best after BWV.
So tell us what your husband thinks after your trip if he's willing to let you talk about his open crying, it'll probably start a big discussion. I hope he doesn't get stuck whining for half of your trip about how he wishes he were at the BWV because both of you could just walk to a few restaraunts and Jellyrolls in the evening, he doesn't like to go down a nice slide at the pool, does he?
As long as we are getting a discussion going, you are going to have at least 5 or more in a one bedroom and your dogs and swipe towels from the pool areas, aren't you?

Kewl.