sayhello
Have Camera, Will Travel
- Joined
- Oct 28, 2006
- Messages
- 16,826
Thank you! I'm so glad you're enjoying my report!Love the report!! Thank you.
Sayhello
Thank you! I'm so glad you're enjoying my report!Love the report!! Thank you.
You are welcome!Thank you for bringing back all these fabulous memories. I was LOL'ing at the bathroom in the Hutong--I remember that VERY well. I couldn't believe how difficult the calligraphy was. I actually took calligraphy when I was young but none of those old skills came backDS Special Needs was NOT a fan of the "magic" toilets at the Ritz, LOL, but I loved them. It is funny how we got the Ritz and were like "this if fine." So spoiled by the hotels on this trip!
You are welcome!Your calligraphy skills were better than mine, so there!
I can just see your DS not appreciating the "magic" toilets! I had enough problems with them myself. And I agree with how spoiled we were by the hotels on this trip! I have a feeling Iceland is going to be a rude awakening for me after China. The rooms really aren't any cheaper than China -- but totally not the quality. Supply and demand, and all! I'm amazed how much more expensive Iceland is compared to when I went just 2 years ago...
Sayhello
The best (#1) was definitely the Beijing Rosewood. Most everyone on our trip seemed to agree with that. The rooms were just beautiful, as was the whole hotel, and the service was wonderful. Next for me was the Hong Kong Peninsula (although I was not a fan of the iPad controls). Shanghai Peninsula was #3. Although it really should have been #2, I found the bedroom area to be worn & tired looking. It really needed an update to bring it up to the standards of the rest of the Suite. The rest of the Suite was spectacular, if a bit too spread out. #4 was the Chengdu Ritz Carlton. There was *nothing* wrong with it, and on any other trip, it would have been fabulous, but it was just a bit out-classed. #5 was the Shangri-La Guilin. The Shangri-La was actually a nice room, the best in Guilin, I'm sure, but it just wasn't up to the standards of the rest of the trip.I'm curious how you would rank the hotels in China. I loved the Ritz, but I know it wasn't as loved by others.
I would have ranked them Shanghai Peninsula, Chengdu Ritz, Guilin Shangri La, [Beijing Peninsula], and [Hong Kong Shangri La]. I was excited to hear they removed my 2 lowest (which were still ok) and added the Beijing Rosewood and HK Peninsula. Yeah, Iceland may be a rude awakening. At least the landscape will be spectacular.
My rank is exactly the same! The first three were neck and neck for me, but there was just something about the rosewood that really hit it for me. Loved the HK Peninsula as well, and maybe it was because the the shanghai peninsula was oversold on the technology but I was disappointed with that aspect--I loved the iPads in the Hong Kong peninsula and though the shanghai was dated in comparison. I was also annoyed that we couldn't set our room to a specific temp at the shanghai. The service there was also a little on the pretentious edge of stuffy. The shangra la was just ok--the meh breakfast kind of killed it for me.The best (#1) was definitely the Beijing Rosewood. Most everyone on our trip seemed to agree with that. The rooms were just beautiful, as was the whole hotel, and the service was wonderful. Next for me was the Hong Kong Peninsula (although I was not a fan of the iPad controls). Shanghai Peninsula was #3. Although it really should have been #2, I found the bedroom area to be worn & tired looking. It really needed an update to bring it up to the standards of the rest of the Suite. The rest of the Suite was spectacular, if a bit too spread out. #4 was the Chengdu Ritz Carlton. There was *nothing* wrong with it, and on any other trip, it would have been fabulous, but it was just a bit out-classed. #5 was the Shangri-La Guilin. The Shangri-La was actually a nice room, the best in Guilin, I'm sure, but it just wasn't up to the standards of the rest of the trip.Again, on any other trip, it would have been great.
I'm looking forward to hearing what you think of the Beijing Rosewood.
And you are correct. The landscape in Iceland is what you go for.I'll survive "utilitarian" hotels!
Sayhello
I can't comment on the breakfast at the HK Peninsula, because I was still dealing with stomach issues, and couldn't really appreciate what they had.Our China ABD group rated the hotels differently. We went with #1 Hong Kong Peninsula, #2 Shanghai Peninsula, #3 Rosewood Beijing, #4 Chengdu Ritz Carlton and #5 Shangri-La Guilin. Maybe this speaks to the fact that the hotels are all really spectacular. I think our group liked the service and locations of the two Peninsulas. The rooms at the Rosewood were huge and amazing, but several of us had trouble getting coffee at breakfast and one older couple in our group encountered a rude concierge. I think this may have affected the rating of the Rosewood. Our guides felt they all had something special to offer:
HK Peninsula - best breakfast
Rosewood Beijing - best room
Chengdu Ritz - best toilet
Shangri-La Guilin - best view
Shanghai Peninsula - best bathroom
These hotels all are really fabulous and I am now forever spoiled!
Our China ABD group rated the hotels differently. We went with #1 Hong Kong Peninsula, #2 Shanghai Peninsula, #3 Rosewood Beijing, #4 Chengdu Ritz Carlton and #5 Shangri-La Guilin. Maybe this speaks to the fact that the hotels are all really spectacular. I think our group liked the service and locations of the two Peninsulas. The rooms at the Rosewood were huge and amazing, but several of us had trouble getting coffee at breakfast and one older couple in our group encountered a rude concierge. I think this may have affected the rating of the Rosewood. Our guides felt they all had something special to offer:
HK Peninsula - best breakfast
Rosewood Beijing - best room
Chengdu Ritz - best toilet
Shangri-La Guilin - best view
Shanghai Peninsula - best bathroom
These hotels all are really fabulous and I am now forever spoiled!
I agree completely. The fabulous hotels were a big part of what I loved so much about the trip. It really took the trip to another level for me (just like when the Balmoral was included in the Scotland itinerary). The HK, Shanghai and Rosewood in particular were all so outstanding that I can see any of them ending up as a top pick. I'm bummed to hear about the service issues at the Rosewood though. I loved my room there, but it was also the food that made it #1 for me. They had my favorite breakfast--the noodles were incredible--and the country kitchen might be my favorite hotel restaurant of all time![]()
CG, so glad you're enjoying the report! It's fun for me, sifting through all my photos for the right ones. I'm glad I went to the show, but I was very jealous of you for the sleep you got! That next morning was *really* rough! (Although, again, totally worth it!) Check your email.I love reading along and reliving all these wonderful memories. I was bummed to miss the show but we all needed sleep desperately. It's fun to see what we missed though. Oh gosh, I can't remember his name either! I'm sure DD would but she's at Uni! I love that picture of my family with our new friends in the panda enclosure! You have to send that one to me. We are basically famous in China now . I may have to get my family t-shirts that day that for Christmas!
Kun! Yay, thanks! I'm glad your memory is better than mine! I keep meaning to write things like the local guides' names down, but I never remember to do it!What a great report of a fabulous day! I love reliving the memories of our ABD China trip. I must say I am a bit jealous you got to see the baby pandas. Our group did not. We went to the face changing opera as well. Several of the families with younger children skipped it or had one parent go with the older children. We even had one little girl from our group get made up in the traditional make up and costume. Although we were definitely sleep deprived the next day, I think it was worth it. I found myself nodding off on every plane and bus ride the next day.
Oh, and the local guide's name was Kun, pronounced coon (like ra-coon). He was our youngest local guide and spoke excellent English. We thought he had lived in the US, but he said he had learned English at the university.
Got it! Thank you so much. That's a keeper!CG, so glad you're enjoying the report! It's fun for me, sifting through all my photos for the right ones. I'm glad I went to the show, but I was very jealous of you for the sleep you got! That next morning was *really* rough! (Although, again, totally worth it!) Check your email.I've sent the photo of you and your fans!!
Sayhello
Oh, and the local guide's name was Kun, pronounced coon (like ra-coon). He was our youngest local guide and spoke excellent English. We thought he had lived in the US, but he said he had learned English at the university.