We originally signed up for Magical Express (because of the FREE factor) but ended up deciding to rent a town car instead.
Here was my thought process . . . I did a lot of research about ME on these boards and read enough bad experiences with slow trip times (long waits at the airport, lots of stops, etc.) and lost or delayed luggage to sell me on NOT taking ME. Now, I know that there could be TONS of responses about how great ME is, but we are getting into Orlando at 11:15am, so we actually have an opportunity to get into the parks that afternoon if we get to Disney FAST, so I considered quick transportation to be a "must."
Next I looked at cabs. (roughly $40 each way, if I remember correctly, BTW - check out the website for Mears cabs - it has a fare calculator). My concern with cabs is that I have a 3 1/2 year old. Under FL law, I think 4 and under must be in car seats. I didn't want to lug a car seat all the way to Orlando just for the ride to and from the airport, so that ruled out cabs.
That brought me to renting a town car, since some of the companies offer free car seats. I ended up reserving through Florida Tours (
fltours.com) - a sponsor of this board. I'm paying about $130 round trip, which includes a car seat and a 30-minute stop at the grocery store (which we're actually skipping, even though it would be great to pick up snacks, because we want to get to the parks!!) Oh, I should mention that as silly as it sounds since there's only 3 of us, I actually had to rent a "luxury van" rather than a Town Car - through Florida Tours, you could only get a booster seat in a Town Car (I called to ask why - it's because they don't have room to store the car seat in the trunk if they have another customer after us). The price difference wasn't that much between the two.
So, we're spending $130 that we don't have to, but if it means another hour (or maybe more) in the parks, it's worth every penny to me! HTH!