I'm in the same boat as jenpink, literally. Sailing into the arm is very exciting for everyone on the ship. Everyone will be out on the deck and it will be freezing cold. I loved it before (on my previous Alaska cruise), but now with the choice of being in a smaller boat with less people sounds even more divine. I'm keeping my noon time. The BBQ was very good, but I'm not a foodie and can easily eat something else.