SnoWhiteRabbit
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Apr 28, 2001
- Messages
- 2,096
disneyjunkie said:I have to agree.
I can't bring myself to pay for something I can get for free.:
It's funny to me that it seems like people are attacking TGM -- saying I didn't find anything in TGM that I didn't find in UG and DIS, which is a bit of an unfair way to critique TGM's worth. I haven't seen any posts in the reverse -- stating, I haven't found anything in UG that I can't find on TGM. Both have valuable information. It should not be "X is no good because *I* got most of it already in Y", but perhaps more accurately, "If you've already read X you might not need Y" or vice versa!
It is interesting to see the comparisons -- those who don't like TGM seems to say: Why pay for online info when I can get other online info for free?
I don't compare TGM to *free* online sites, I compare TGM to the Passporter BOOK, Unofficial Guide BOOK - each which cost about the same as TGM. I can't get the Unofficial Gudie BOOK for free or the Passporter BOOK for free. I am willing to *pay* for both books, just as I am willing to *pay* for Tour GUide MIke, which to me is an excellent guide BOOK, which is accessible online, providing the added benefit of constant updates --- an added value!
When you think of it this way, why would you be willing to pay for other books, but not Tour Guide Mike? It's like buying a book that constantly updates itself! My 2004 copies of the Passporter and The Unofficial Guide have not updated themselves --- in fact the Passporter and UG are usually outdated by the time you buy them (...didn't have the EMH changes, did the 2005 versions have the MMY changes?....) I know both books offer changes on their sites, but I have to read the book first, then check for changes online -- Tour Guide Mike offers it all in one place.
As for TGM being a bunch of articles, isn't that what travel books are? Articles grouped together in chapters, etc, accessible through a table of contents and/or index...TGM offers info in the same way.
I've bought the 2000, 2001, 2002, and 2004 UG & Passporter, and TGM in 2004. For my 2005 trip, I'll use the 2004 UG, Passporter and a new subscription to TGM! Between the 3 resources and these boards, I know I'll be in great shape. However, I also know TGM will provide info that I won't find anywhere else.
I'm not sure TGM is a *must buy* any more than The Passporter or UG...In reality having only 1 of these resources is *probably* enough or just using allears and the DIS boards for free is probably enough, but for Disney Info Junkies like many of us here, it is not unreasonable or a waste to purcahse more than one "guide book" - Passporter, UG and TGM. All 3 or great resources!
A definite TGM fan here! I have most certainly found things on TGM that I have not found in the Passporter or The Unofficial Guide -- both which I have read cover to cover several times, several different years. I am glad to use all three.