Tony's v Plaza - help me choose pls

[aubriee]

I really appreciate everyone's opinion. To answer a previous question, yes, I'm on the dining plan which is probably why I'm having such a hard time deciding but now I'm done to lunch at either Plaza or LTT and leaning more towards LTT.

Hello fellow Texan! I'm not a fan of the Plaza. It's OK, but just your basic sandwich shop. If on the DxDDP I might be willing to waste a credit on it, but if on the basic DDP there is no way. It's a good restaurant if you need to pay for one out of pocket.

With Tony's you never seem to know what you're going to get. I've had the best steak I've ever had there, along with a wonderful amaretta cheesecake that was heavenly and my favorite dessert that trip. However, we've also had a couple of not so good meals there, both before and after that wonderful steak. I l also had a really good eggplant stack there a couple of times.

We don't care for LTT for dinner, but do enjoy if for lunch. If I was looking for a consistently good lunch I'd go with LTT over the other two or better yet leave the park and catch the monorail over to the GF Cafe.

 

[Mr. Disney 1986]

Of the two, Tony’s. I love the chicken parm with the ice cream bomb.

 

[Ninnygunk]

We've eaten at both & far prefer the Plaza. It's a shame to waste a TS meal for a sandwich - however - those sandwiches are better than most meals from Tony's IMHO. Just depends on your taste I suppose. Plaza is beautiful and the atmosphere is great! Servers have always been fantastic & the desserts are well worth the visit. I did have some shrimp pasta at Tony's that was tasty. Lasagna very dry & not much variety to choose from. Happy eating...........

 

[Ramsfan28]

Tony's is horrible in my opinion, it is VERY bad Italian "food".

 

[marielynn724]

Plaza's food is consistently good, whereas so many people report horrible food at Tony's. I've been there a few times myself and it was always really disappointing.

 

[chocovrdmicears]

Are you on the dining plan? The reason I ask is that that is precisely why we have never eaten at the Plaza. I refuse to "waste" a TS credit on sandwiches and burgers. sorry, just my opinion
On the other hand, we have never had a bad dinner at Tonys'. Great no. Perfectly adequate, yes. We've eaten many times at LTT for lunch and dinner and have always really enjoyed ourselves. It's definitely our favourite TS at MK (especially since we no longer have little ones begging for character meals).

We ate at both the Plaza and Tonys's during our trip using the Dining Plan.

The Plaza was outstanding - Yes, we had sandwiches. Delicious ones I might add, and the perfect crispy, salted steak fries and amazingly, crazy good desserts.
Tony's was terrible. The food was inedible and the service was terrible.

$ for $ our Dining Credit may have been best used at Tony's. But without a doubt the real *waste of a Dining Credit* was at Tony's. In the future I would choose The Plaza for my Dining credit a million times over Tony's.

 

[disneygirlmass]

My vote would be for the Plaza...I ate at Tony's and it was very disappointing...the Plaza has better food and it's cheaper

 

[Disneyx6]

I have to agree with the PP's that Tony's is horrible! We have tried Tony's 2x just to be sure we didn't have an off night the 1st time. It was horrible twice! Our last trip in Oct. we had 4 adults and 4 kids and none of us finished anything! A complete waste of a TS if you ask me.