Tony's Town Square vs. O'hana dinner

[Maddie2]

HELP! I've just made ADR's and I can't decide between these two:

Tony's Town Square @ 7:40pm OR
O'Hana dinner @ the Polynesian @ 9:30.

(I reserved both and will call to cancel one)

Normally, 9:30 is extremely late for us to eat dinner, but when at WDW, time is completely different. We'll be spending the entire day at Magic Kingdom, so either location is convenient.

Our other ADR's are LeCellier, Mama Melrose, Sci Fi Drive-In and Cape May Character breakfast.

 

[ptrbryant]

I just couldn't decide between Tony's and 'Ohana...we've never been to either one. Speaking with a CM, she recommended 'Ohana because, as she put it, you can go to an Italian restaurant just about anywhere, but where else are you going to have an experience like 'Ohana?

It made sense to me and I decided to go with 'Ohana. We'll find out next month how we like it!

Karla B.

 

[karliebug]

definitely O'hanas. It is fun and delicious and all you can eat. Although 9:30 would be much too late for my kids-if it works for you than go for it.Also, since you have a late ressie you may get to view the fireworks from the window-awesome.

 

[TikiGoddess]

I've been to both and would say Ohana without a doubt. It was the best place we ate last trip (January) and that trip included Le Cellier. The atmosphere is really fun and the food keeps moving so you won't be there forever that late at night. The turkey is the best turkey I've ever eaten in my entire life. Have fun!

 

[Maddie2]

I was leaning towards O'hana -- and you all just confirmed it. Thank you!!

Question --- is rice served with the meal? One website mentioned rice, but all the other websites state a variety of meats, wontons, stir-fry veggies and bread pudding for dessert. So, rice or no rice? Thanks!