I have to say no. Maybe things have changed, but two years ago we tried both versions--ordered Tonga Toast at Captain Cooks because we'd loved it so much at Kona earlier in our trip. We found that the CC version was a pale imitation. The bread was hard and tough. Filling was the same. Maybe we just had bad luck?
I do like the strawberry sauce, fwiw, but DH doesn't and we both detected a big difference.