Toes- always polished, always dark red or dark brown; been using Revlon Autumn Berry for a while.
Fingers- can't seem to keep polish on them. Usually do a nude, a gold/copper, or a medium brown for work-- something tame. Will do dark reds & dark browns for night, but usually I'm too lazy to do them.
Don't ever buy Revlon Colorstay! It's horrible! It's impossible to remove with remover, but it will peel off. Plus, it got all goopy within about 2 weeks-- impossible to apply neatly after that.