So truthfully the only time I thought the
ddp was a good value was when the tips are included.
Most of the time though, unless you eat a bunch of character meals and/or buffets the dining plan is not going to save you wads of cash.
Now the Disney plan cost 58 bucks per person. so no way in heck would we eat 240 dollars a day for food. (my kids are considered adults)
My first tip is to figure out how you really eat, day in and day out.
Also it helps me to calculate the weekly cost not just daily spending. what did you order on the ddp that you would not pay cash for? I'm betting that there are very few things.
I found that when I'm on the ddp (and I know others do it) I tend to order not what I want but what's the most expensive simply to make sure I get the most out of my points. Then I try to rationalize it by saying 'I would never order that and pay oop". LOL the truth is I would never order steak every night anyway, nor lobster
It's funny when I question folks about "watching" the menu price, in reality they do it more on the ddp.
So normally would you go to a signature restaurant 7 nights on vacation or do a character meal 6 nights?
For my family "snacks" where the big ticket thing. For a while we were buying tons of ice cream, candy and such just because we were at Disney.
We always have a car so also what we do is have a big breakfast offsite. right outside of DTD is an Ihop, a denny's and a Perkins pancake house. I hop always had the 4.99 breakfast so for 20 bucks before tip we got pancakes,eggs, 2 pieces of a meat for each of us. rarely did we want lunch on those days.