When we were at the GF in Nov. there was one guy who took our bags out of the car, one who asked if he could valet park our car(we declined and DH parked it in the lot)and then a different guy who took our bags and us to the room. We tipped the guy who took our bags out of the car and all he did was load it on to the cart thing with mine and my DH help, so we only gave him $2, trust me, he should have tipped us! Anyway, the bellhop, took our luggage, waited for us to check in, then drove us around showing us where everything was, took our stuff and us to our room and showed us around and made sure everything was to our liking. We tipped him $10. I do think $5 for just parking a car is alot, am I crazy? We usually tip well and try to be fair, but I think $2-$3 is sufficient if all he/she is doing is parking the car. I would also like to know if those who tip valet $5, do you tip the same for in/out like for dinner?