Tiime share. Do you? Would you?

Charade

<font color=royalblue>I'm the one on the LEFT side
Joined
Jan 2, 2005
Messages
26,067
One our last day at WDW this week (it rained), my GF went to a Sheraton time share presentation really just for the free gift but the offer sounded good (I didn't buy). So if you own a time share (not DVC) or thought about one could you share your pros and cons?
 
No, and no. I like to go to different places and stay in all kinds of hotels. Additionally, what if my income situation changed and I was locked into this thing? I wouldn't do it and really don't "get" why people do. Maybe someone can enlighten me.
 
Pugdog007 said:
No, and no. I like to go to different places and stay in all kinds of hotels. Additionally, what if my income situation changed and I was locked into this thing? I wouldn't do it and really don't "get" why people do. Maybe someone can enlighten me.


I wouldn't want to be locked into the same place either but this program allows you to use other time share locations (other than your "home" resort)/hotels and other hotels via their points program using a time share broker.
 

i've been to several timeshare presentations and never opted to buy in because i could not see going to the same place at the same time every year. i also did not want to buy in with the mind of using other locations (if it's a great location it's going to be hard to book into).

that said-i am a dvc member (i do not view it as a time share in the traditional sense).
 
Hi - i own 3 weeks with a British based company called Seasons which we love - we are NOT fixed into the same week or the same place - we have 7 home resorts, over a 100 affiliated ones and then we can exchange. We also have the choice of weekend and midweek breaks at them!! We have saved a fair amount (£1,000s in fact) over the years.
We also own a week with Marriotts which we are not quite so happy with - that we could do without and rent cheaper!!!!! (also we could get into Orlando Marriotts at the times we want to travel with our 'Seasons' weeks!!!)

It isnt for everyone but for us its great and we only wish we had done it when our family had been a lot younger!!!
 
If they're really set on buying, they should purchase a re-sale. The only timeshare I would buy is DVC, but that's not in the financial plan until the house is paid off.
 
We were just talking about this at work the other day...TS owners in the group were regretting their decisions, which worked for them at the time, but no longer. Reasons: 1. Lack of flexibility in their vacation times. 2. cost increases due to hurricane(s) impacts over the past year (Florida only). 3. once they've seen the area of the TS for years, there's little else to do except travel away from the TS. 4. and the sad truth that it's extremely difficult to unload the TS when you are done with it :sad2: It's probably not what you want to hear, but no good news from them. I have no interest in slotting my family into one vacation in one location year after year. Even with WDW, we like to rotate with other trips. My advice is to pass and set that money aside in a liquid interest bearing account to use for your vacations. :earsgirl: :earsboy: :earsboy: :earsgirl:
 
Check out the "Orlando Hotels & Attractions" forum on the DIS.

You'll see that you can rent timeshares for ALOT less than buying.

Last year, we stayed a week at Summer Bay Resort for $264 / wk. (about 8 miles from Disney)

This year, we'll be staying at Cypress Pointe Grande Villas for $221 / wk. (about 1 mile from Downtown Disney) From www.skyauction.com

Why would anyone buy when you can get these rates. Both places are 2 bedroom / 2 bath w/ full kitchens & washer & dryer.
 
Many years ago I bought a timeshare, off the internet, sight unseen and HAVE NEVER BEEN THERE, for only $300. It is outside the Orlando area---Lake Hartwell, South Carolina. yes--three hundred dollars total. It is life-time deeded and I can "will" it to my son. I bought what is called a "red week"--which is the highest 'value" and in a regular resort--not Gold Crown or anything spectacular. I pay a yearly $311 maintenance fee, $89 to belong to RCI and then $149 to exchange into the Orlando area. So for roughly $550 I have been able to get 2 - 3 bedroom condos, Gold Crown status in the Orlando area for our vacations. That being said--we normally do off season trips. At peak times I find I run the risk of getting just "standard" units--which are still usually nicer than just a hotel room. (But I just use that as an excuse to stay onsite). I have been unable to exchange to the beach in July but have never had a problem with getting something in the Orlando area at anytime.

While I think I would love to own in the Orlando area, the purchase price is always WAAAAAYYYY higher than the $300 I paid, the maintenance fees are a lot higher, I don't want to be tied into the same week at the same place each year, and for what I paid up front I feel I get good value for money exchanging what I own--even with the fee. The resale market of timeshares is lousy so unless it was something I was POSITIVE would work every year for me I'd be leary of making that big of a purchase. You also need to think of the way you will vacation in the future--for instance, once you have kids will you want to stay onsite to give them that experience, will you vacation with grandparents in tow so need the space a condo has, etc etc.

I also think the economy has an impact on how I travel/how much of a deal I think my timeshare is. When the economy is good, people are traveling, hotel room deals are harder to find. When the economy is not so good, you can find hotel deals that work out cheaper/almost as cheap as owning a timehsare. For instance, I have a 3 bedroom unit at Hilton grand Vacation Club reserved in January. Disney runs rates of $49 per night in the Values for AP holders. My DGS is DYING to go to Pop--for 7 nights at Pop it would be roughly $385. Less $$$ than my timeshare, not as much room as a 3 bedroom, but onsite and would make my DGS happy. Plus, as others have mentioned--through skyauction, and other means you can find deals on condos. If you are a Government employee--of any kind of Government not just Federal--- RCI has the www.getravelop.com website that allows you to rent their excess inventory for $264 per week.

I would not pay a large of sum of money to own a timeshare, but for what I paid I feel I got a good deal and am usually happy with it. I did try to sell it this past year but the Ebay deal feel through so I have decided to keep it.
 
I own DVC and would only buy a timeshare if it offered that kind of flexibility and was a reputable company. I understand the Marriott timeshare program is a good one as well.

We researched our DVC purchase to death before we bought it, and my DH is a realtor!!! Timeshares are one of those "buyer beware" things. Do oyur homework.

because we did our homework, we have been very happy wioth DVC, have had no real surprises in terms of what to expect, how the program is administered.
 
NO
:)
I have researched it - and I understand it -
but still have no interest in it.

(funny story a friend of ours was GIVEN a week of timewhasre use by her new BIL for a wedding gift... he gave her the book to pick from... well she kept picking ones that weren't in the book :confused3 he had to explain it to her 3 x that she could ONLY stay at one in the books)

I like to be flexible when vacationing...
 
Thanks for the feedback and I'll check out those other resources.

I too would not but into a program that locked me into one week of the year at one specific place. The program I looked at was similar to DVC. You buy "points" at your "home" resort. If you use the points in low season, you can stay longer in a larger unit. If you use the points in the high season, you stay a shorter time in a smaller unit. You can also use the RCI system and "exchange" or broker your time share within the network (for a fee of course). You also get Sheraton "points" to use at their hotels. This seems to be the biggest difference (at least that's what THEY said :teeth: ). They also offered an every other year program (for less than the every year plan) and you used the RCI system on the off years.
 
We bought a resale Vistana floating week in 1998 and it has been great for us. We have traded it twice (such a hassle) and have finally just decided to use it every year instead. The number one rule of timeshare is to buy where you want to go.

For me, it's been great, because it's helped convince my dh to keep going back to Orlando again and again and again!!

If anyone is interested in buying, they should visit www.tug2.net and read before buying.
 
That's the place I looked at although I thought they said it was only 5 years old. There are two Vistana's that I know of. Maybe one is older than the other. The one I looked at was on International drive near Seaworld. Phase one is almost sold out with others coming.
 
We went on the Sheraton tour the last time we visited. When we bought Vistana, it was not Sheraton. Be very careful with their point system. They wanted us to upgrade for $10,000 and by looking at their system, we couldn't even get the weeks we already can!

ex: They don't clearly state that a certain amount of points can get you to the Caribbean, but only in the summer! I kept pressing our salesperson for the real facts and she was getting so mad!

I think that if you are a couple, no kids, it's a great plan and you could get a lot out of it. Sorry, we don't fly our family of five for long weekends, etc!

One thing that I have noticed with timeshare tours that I have been on, only Disney gives you ALL the info and lets you leave with it to review.

ETA: Yes, the new Vistana is Vistana Villages.
 
If you are thinking the word timeshare you should go to www.tug2.net it is the best resource in the world....

We do own DVC & we recently bought a week at a timeshare in NC to use for trading... we bought that week CHEAP & it allows us TWO weeks exchange using Interval International... we put in one week, we get two out... apparently II has a shortage from that resort... anyhow, you have to be smart in regards to timeshares, or you'll be STUCK big time.... and I agree, using Skyauction at times is a fantastic bargain!
 
We have a time share, and rarely use it. I think it just takes too much pre-planning for us at this point. You have to decide so far ahead of time where you want to go and when, and with 2 small children we don't do as much traveling as we'd like.

We haven't used it in 4 years and it's such a waste. Every year when we get the bill for the taxes on it I get sick to my stomach. It costs about $1000 to list it for sale with no guarantee of a sale, so I feel like we're stuck. But if you're organized, travel a lot, and do your research it might be a good idea for you.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom