focusondisney
DIS Legend
- Joined
- May 7, 2009
- Messages
- 16,581
I see your point. I agree that you shouldn't use crowd calendars. They'll never do the thing you're looking for.
The concerns I'd have with trying to measure "feels crowded" as a metric are:
So we can't measure it, and even if we could, nobody would agree on what it means. That is not a great basis for analysis.
- It's subjective. Everyone's definition is going to be different. And everyone's definition is correct -for that one specific person.
- It's almost impossible to measure on a daily basis to determine crowds. Other than standing in the parking lot and asking people as they leave, I don't know how we'd do it.
The advantage to using posted wait times are that they're objective and easy to verify.
They're not perfect - they're often wrong in ways that limit how accurate an analysis can be.
But they solve those two issues, and they allow us to do at least some analysis work.
I guess I didn’t explain myself well. I didn’t say I don’t believe or use the crowd calendars. I’ve subscribed to your site for as long as I can remember & understand how & why your calendar operates the way it does. Not everyone does tho so I’m just pointing out that the parks may sometimes feel different than the numbers listed. It’s just something to keep in mind when using the site. The information you provide is objective data, but other factors, like Disney playing with staffing or people mingling in walkways play a part in how crowded the parks feel. For me personally, I like knowing your numbers, even if the park feels more crowded to me than they show. It helps me set my expectations when I see that number going forward. Plus I love participating by submitting posted & my own timed wait times.
Last edited: