I've been to both Medieval Times and the Pirates dinner and enjoyed them thoroughly. I'd give the edge to Medieval Times. The main meal is a big piece of roasted chicken, corn, and mashed potatoes, You get some soup as a starter, and dessert as well. Each time I've been there I found the chicken to be very juicy and tasty. There's a vegetarian option as well, but I'm not sure what you get. The food is really secondary to the show.