We stayed at the Sagamore on Disney points at the end of last September. We went for a romantic weekend without the kids. It was incredible. The grounds are magnificant and the views from the steps and patios behind the Veranda will take your breath away.
We ate at the Trillium, Mr. Brown's, and had afternoon tea and evening drinks at the Veranda. We also ate breakfast in the Sagamore room. They are all different experiences. Bring a good range of clothing. The Trillium is absolutely elegant. The service and atmosphere alone make it worth the price, and, of course, the food is to die for. Jackets are required for men there. It's a nice chance to do something really special and be really pampered.
Mr. Brown's is very casual and the food is also excellent. The price range there was very moderate. It won't break your bank and you'll enjoy your meal. It is decorated to highlight the natural beauty of the area. It's an upscale pub.
The Veranda is just that - an old veranda with wicker furniture. They had jazz performances there in the afternoon and evening while we were there. You can get light meals (finger sandwich-type food), drinks, and afternoon tea. The Veranda spills outdoors onto stepped terraces with Adirondack furniture. The landscaping is unique, and this area looks right out over Lake George. There is waiter/waitress service outside. And you're in for a special treat at night out there. I won't ruin it for you. Just go back out there after dark!
The Sagamore room is where they serve breakfasts and all the views are wonderful. Try to get a seat by a window. This room is so very pretty, classic Victorian. The breakfast spread will fill you up until dinner. The most difficult decision of your day will be how to limit yourself with all the choices there.
We enjoyed the Lodge suite. It is very spacious and we were lucky enough to get a perfect view of the lake. However, if I have one criticism of the Sagamore, it is that the Lodges scream 1980s, while the rest of the island is turn-of-the-century post-Victorian. Someone completely lost the theme of the island when they added those condos.
The condos (Lodges) are decorated in an Adirondack theme, but a very tasteful version. They are comfortable units.
We toured the rooms in the old hotel and decided they were far more romantic, so we've booked one of those rooms with a lake view for this coming fall. Yes, we loved the Sagamore and we're going back.
The Sagamore has regular surrey rides around the property (horse-drawn carriages). They also have a state-of-the art gym, a spa, an indoor pool, etc. You'll be occupied well.
You should really visit their web site at
http://www.thesagamore.com/html/index2.html
It looks too beautiful to be true, but it is as grand as the Web site portrays. I could go on forever with more details, but I think you'll see for yourself that this is a special place worth using those points for.
Have a wonderful stay!