The Plaza or Tonys?

[10pointsforgaston]

I went to Tonys for the first time because my mom really wanted to, and we liked it. The food isn't that great but our server was wonderful, and it was a pleasant experience overall. Doesn't hurt to give it a try.

 

[CuteAsMinnie]

The Plaza is GREAT! There is a certain time over lunch that they only take walk ups... maybe 11-12? Or 12-1? I forget. We did that and waited only 15 minutes (in early May). It's a pretty place, service is great, the view is great, the food is great.

I'm told Tony's spaghetti is of the canned taste variety. Think spaghetti o's, but we've never been.

 

[magical-me]

Tony's is lacking in the good food department. Plaza is wayyyyyy better by a lot.

 

[tellemarie]

We go to Tony's every trip on our last night, but I'm going to side with the (what seems like) majority. I've never been disappointed but Plaza and lately the quality at Tony's has been lacking.