I have a little problem maybe you guys can help with, not so much related to being a new mommy though, just something with my SIL. My SIL has been telling her mom and sister that she wants a divorce since December. She's been married since July 2000 and they have 2 kids (almost 4 and 21 months). Well a couple of months later my MIL told my husband about his sister wanting a divorce, and basically their thoughts were that it was because her friend is getting a divorce so she wants one too.
Well, they don't make much money, and my SIL has bas spending habits, so my husband and I were thinking that had a lot to do with their issues, but he never really talked to her about it so all our info was through MIL. Today she sent me an e-mail explaining all their problems and why she wants a divorce. She said since they got married he's been yelling at her all the time, calling her cell phone and cursing at her for not answering it, staying up all night playing Playstation, then doesn't want to wake up till after noon, leaving her and the kids alone. He never helps with their kids and she was afraid to tell him she was pregnant with the 2nd and when she did call him he hung up on her. He later apologized, but still, not how he should act. They have seen a therapist and since she told him she wants a divorce she said he's been a changed man, but in her mind she can't get over that he wasn't willing to change just because he loves her, but only because he doesn't want to be alone. He tells her that she knew that he played Playstation, didn't cook, clean, or help with new babies before they got married so she should have married him. She said she used to cry and worry all the time but now she doesn't seem to care and the therapist said it's cause she's building a defense against him. She also said if the marriage were a year old she could help them, but 4 years is a long time to be hurt. Her big worry (and my MIL and SIL's) is how their kids will be affected, but the therapist told her they'll be fine, that they'll adjust.
She's not asking for advice, just wanted to tell me (we're pretty close, but we live far from them and see them maybe once or twice a year) so we know what's going on and aren't shocked if we hear she filed. (She doesn't know MIL told us.) Well, she told me to tell my husband not to tell his mom anything that she told us cause she doesn't want her to know that she told us (MIL is trying to get her to stay married and I think she feels if she keeps talking to people and getting support she'll be more likely to leave-not that MIL won't support her either way, she will, but she'd rather see them stay together). Well, if I tell my husband, he will almost definitely tell his mom, so I was thinking I just won't tell him. Like MIL, he doesn't want her to leave him either, but he's been sticking up for the husband mostly, saying he works so hard and she spends so much and she needs to stop buying things and stop having kids (2nd child was not planned, but just as much her fault as his!). But at the same time, I don't want to not tell him, cause it's his sister, and she's very obviously hurting in this relationship and he needs to know that and see that she's not just getting a divorce cause her friend did. I'd love to see her have a happy marriage too, but she said she no longer loves him, there's no chemistry, and basically it seems like she's been through some emotional abuse which she shouldn't have to take. If she feels she needs to divorce him, that's a very tough, personal decision for her that I don't think anyone else should get to weigh in on. It's obviously not something she's taking lightly.
So I don't know what to do, whether I should tell him or not. And I also don't know what to respond to her. I want to tell her that yes, the kids will be fine, it will be hard for all of them, but they'll adjust, and if she's being emotionally abused then they'd all be better off without living with him, but I don't want to seem like I want her to leave. I think her husband is a great guy, but I don't have to live with him. I think he loves his kids and her, but if she doesn't feel it and if he doesn't want to take any responsibility for them or spend time with the family then they won't know how he feels. Ugh, I was totally not expecting this and up to this point I really didn't think she had a basis for wanting to leave him. Sorry this was so long, I just needed to get an outside POV.