The Official American Idol Season 8 Thread.

[Captain Brain]

When Kelly sang last night it sounded like Allison. I could see her singing songs like Kelly does.

In today's pop world, that would make her a success.

 

[disneychick2721]

That was the first time I was ever quoted three times. XD

Oh wow I just noticed that.
xD

When Kelly sang last night it sounded like Allison. I could see her singing songs like Kelly does.

 

[jobrosx0disney]

i pretty much like everyone.

My Faves:
Alexis
Meghan
Danny
Allison
Matt
Lil

I also like:
Anoop
Adam


I think that this season has some REALLY talented people in it!!

 

[crazytp93]

I think Lil might surprise us.

Last year I was a Syesha Mercado fan. And she mad it into the top 3.

I think the final 2 could be Danny and Adam.

 

[Captain Brain]

Noooo, final two should be Kris and Alexis/Allison. As long as any of those three make it, I'll be a happy viewer.

 

[crazytp93]

Yeah.

I just get the Cook/Archuleta feeling when I see Adam and Danny.

I'm not a fan of Adam at all, but I'd like to see Danny make it.

 

[Princess victoria]

Adam Lambert is definitly my favorite.
but i like Kris allen and Allison Iraheta too.

 

[crazytp93]

I give Adam a 3 out of 10 for tonight.
His act is getting old.
And honestly, his vocals sucked.

 

[wdwllamadancer]

i love adam. he's really cool. i loved the spin he put on it.

 

[Captain Brain]

No one should be able to do Ring of Fire. I am disappointed beyond belief.

Lil should NOT have done Independence Day either. That song is iconic, and it doesn't fit her style at all. DAY.

Kris and Allison did amazingly. Garth and Patty ftw.

 

[crazytp93]

Lil really messed up on the song choice.
But I wished she did more in the beggining of what she did at the end.

Lil should be safe.

 

[saratogadreamin09]

I think Adam's performance will give me nightmares


Now that I got that out of the way


Michael - good, not the best but good and he has a future in country

Allison - ok, it was good but she should avoid country, not her genre

Lil - Good but it was a song carrie underwood sang and she didnt do it like carrie

Kris - BEST OF THE NIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! His voice sounded so pure and great

Meghan - ok, didnt WOW me but it was good, i think she actually has to go though

Anoop - good, he's getting better week by week

Alexis - great, she has such raw, natural talent

Scott - good, i like him just playing the piano, his voice is another one thats very pure

Danny - WRONG SONG CHOICE, IMO girls shouldnt even sing carrie underwood, no male on earth should go for it it sounded off and wrong

Matt - his breathing was off, bad song choice, he was one of my favs but no anymore

Adam - cant say enough bad things about it, i agree with everything simon said about it, it wasnt country at ALL, its actually what i think michael jackson would look and sound like singing country



My favs are Kris, Michael, Scott, and Alexa

Adam has to go but he wont, Meghan, Matt and Alexa might be in danger




I belive there are untouchable artists and Carrie Underwood is one of them, you just cant sing here she's WAY too good

 

[chisnpeke]

No one should be able to do Ring of Fire. I am disappointed beyond belief.

Lil should NOT have done Independence Day either. That song is iconic, and it doesn't fit her style at all. DAY.

Kris and Allison did amazingly. Garth and Patty ftw.

Except Joaquin Phoenix. He really did nail Ring of Fire. I love that song.

 

[chisnpeke]

Adam was too "out there" tonight. Did not like that version at ALL.

I like Danny. I also like Alexis.

 

[Axel]

I give Adam a 3 out of 10 for tonight.
His act is getting old.
And honestly, his vocals sucked.

Adam gets a 0 out of 10 from me. I don't normally like him to begin with, but that was HORRIBLE! I turned off Fox halfway in because I couldn't stand it!

But I did love Danny's song. I think he sang it better than Carrie (mostly because I hate her voice and I hate how, if you listen closely, you can hear the synthesizers on her high notes).

 

[::Snow_White::]

I watch it occasionally.

My mom is in love with Danny but she didn't like his preformance last night and loved Adam Lamberts.
I didn't like it, it kinda creeped me out.

Go Anoop! I loved him last night.
He's my favorite.
I thought Meghan did a good job too. I like how she sang that song.

 

[crazytp93]

Adam gets a 0 out of 10 from me. I don't normally like him to begin with, but that was HORRIBLE! I turned off Fox halfway in because I couldn't stand it!

But I did love Danny's song. I think he sang it better than Carrie (mostly because I hate her voice and I hate how, if you listen closely, you can hear the synthesizers on her high notes).

The 3 was me being nice.
I didn't want to get attacked by the Adam fans on this thread. =PPP

 

[crazytp93]

Dial Idol got lasts weeks right (except for Allison having less votes than Jasmine, but it was within the range of error.)

Here is this weeks

Bolded is predicted to be safe
Italics predicted to be in danger of being voted off.

(In order of most votes to least votes)

1. Danny Gokey
2. Anoop Desai
3. Lil Rounds
4. Matt Giraud
5. Kris Allen
6. Adam Lambert
7. Michael Sarver
8. Scott MacIntyre

9. Megan Joy Corkey
10. Allison Irahetta
11. Alexis Grace

 

[PosessedEeyore]

i have to admit, adams performance last night was slightly scary.
it wasnt really the singing that scared me, it was the looks he gave the camera!
he seriously looked like he was goona come kill somebody.
and when he started to sing i was like WTH!
i still love him, and hope he makes it through, which i believe he will.

 

[pitt02]

I thought Danny did the best last night followed by Matt and Anoop; on the other hand Adam did awful.
I agree with those rankings but i believe Scott should be over Micheal and Adam.
And if Paula is going to critsize Scott for being on the piano twice in a row then you also have to critisize Matt for the same thing.