Where: Yachstman steakhouse
credit: 4 table service
Items: 2 sodas,seared Maine Diver scallops, chilled seafood salad, yachstman filet, porterhouse, mushrooms, chocolate study, cheese tray
approx cost including tax (not tip):$144.00
review: A-
After the wonderful meal at Tutto we returned to the BW to work off our meal so that we would be prepared for tonight's dinner at the Yacht Club. Of course it began pouring right before dinner but luckily we did not have far to go!
When we arrived at the Yachtsman we were quickly seated and again like Narcoossee's given anniversary menus. We took a look at the cuts of meat and the desserts on display. The server was such a nice lady and we had wonderful service.
both appetizers were spectacular. The scallops were cooked perfectly and the seafood sald so fresh. I ordered the filet with a red wine sauce and mashed potatoes. While personally I perfer the filets at Jiko and Cali grill over this one , I enjoyed my meal. The filet was buttery soft, cooked perfectly med. The redwine sauce was not overpowering and the potatoes creamy but still resembles the consitency of potato and not some forgein pasty substance

The mushrooms I could have lived with out. I have had much better at the steakhouses here in NY. To me they were a bit bland and the sauce was slimy- DH liked them though. Dh however did not enjoy his meal and this is why I gave it a grade of A- and not A.
Now I should say that DH and I met many,many years ago working in a steakhouse here in NYC so we are a bit picky when it comes to this. Anyway a steak is as much about the cut of meat as it is being properly cooked. We hate our steaks overdone and like them MR-M. Red in the center but warm not cool or cold which woul be rare. Dh ordered the Porterhouse Med and it came out rare- the thing was cold in the center. I didn't believe him but felt it for myself and sure enough it was basically raw. Anyway he didn't want to send it back because that is just the way he is and so ate anyway and did not enjoy it. I think had he sent it back he would have enjoyed his meal much better but I think this was a error on the kitchen because they shouldn't have put both steaks on at the same time (which is most likely what they did) Dh is a stickler for things like that and very picky. All in all though a very good meal.So lessson if you are not happy with the way the steak comes out imo you should send it back!
I would most likely pick Jiko, CG or FF over it but still very nice ambience and very good service. I would definitely recommend it for steak lovers.Also if you are paying oop I think this is a pretty good deal as most places here in NY are a la carte and so the bill really adds up. I thought it was a great value for the quality of food and service.
Ignore Mousepotato's silly face

...I wanted to show you the elgant mission style interior...
very good bread sreved with butter and a delish spreadable roated garlic..
Amazing scallops..
filet..
Porterhouse (dh substituted mash for the fingerlings)
shrooms
cheese tray..
one of the best choc desserts anywhere..
A nice gift from our server..
Oh yes and after all of that DH still got a funnel cake at Tasty Sensations on the BW. So I got an Italian ice. Funnel cake was good as usual. italian Ice- bleck. Skip it. I am not sure what they served me. It was hab=nd scooped and pre frozen and frost bitten. I should have returned it but ahhh whatever I still ate it lol! It was a hot night and the ice was tempting lol!
Up Next...Jambo! We adventure to Africa and dine at tusker house for lunch and Jiko for dinner.