Correlation does not imply causation. This will only be our second trip to WDW, but we go to DL about once a year. The same things could be said about food at DL -- homogenized menus, shrinking portions, decline in quality, advance reservations required. Here's the thing:
DL does not have a dining plan. What DL DOES have is the same Disney executives making decisions about how they are going to increase profit from food service.
The
DDP did not cause the changes -- the DDP
is part of the changes. Disney management
wants the restaurants full, all year round, even in hurricane season. They
want all of their guests to plan on eating at least one TS meal a day, and to expect that as part of the overall "Disney experience". They
want to cut costs on the food with smaller portions, fewer specialty or expensive ingredients, more basic menus throughout all Disney restaurants so they get better deals from the suppliers. It's a lot cheaper to buy the exact same salmon fillets for 10 different restaurants, and serve them up with 10 different sauces and garnishes, than to special order for each individual location. Then each location maintains its individual identity and appeal with a couple of signature dishes and/or desserts (cheddar cheese soup and maple creme brulee at Le Cellier, Cobb Salad and grapefruit cake at Brown Derby, etc.)
I never got to experience WDW dining at the peak of its glory days, and I'm sorry to have missed it. But so many people visit every single day, they just can't consistently provide the gourmet, boutique, unique dining experiences they once did. The closest you will come to that is the signature restaurants, and you will pay a premium to eat there -- looks like prices are going up across the board. A lot.
The Tahitian Terrace at DL used to serve a teriyaki steak for 3.25...of course, that was 1969...times change!

I was bowled over by the prices at Blue Bayou in February, and even lunch at Cafe Orleans was a lot more than it was a couple of years ago.
Me thinks Disney is trying to do what most companies do. Increase revenue and decrease expenses. With food prices on the rise, it only makes sense that they streamline meal choices and find a single supplier to cut them a deal. Doesn't make me happy but makes sense.
We will be doing more and more off site dining.
I agree...and since you have that option, I can certainly understand why you would. But I think the vast majority of visitors will be more like us -- flew in from out of state, took ME from the airport, no rental car, don't know Orlando anyway, don't want to miss anything so will stay on site, spending all of our money for food, lodging, entertainment, and everything else...at Disney.
And Disney is counting on that.
