I dont' see how anyone could hate Showboat! It's a classic! When flash in the pan shows like Wicked and Spring Awakening are long forgotten...Showboat will still be a standard bearer for American musical theatre!
I just don't understand how people enjoy Wicked! I found the show mind numbing and dull. The score was fairly vanilla except for one or two songs which is typical for a Stephen Shwartz show. Plus they butchered the novel!
I've never quite undertood the allue of Webber's shows either. Save for Evita his shows are uneven and less than engaging. Don't even get me started on his Phantom sequel...it may be a sign of the end times coming!
I look to shows by Cole Porter or the Gershwins for great shows!
As much as I adore Cole Porter and the Gershwins, as well as Richard Rogers and the rest of that group....I love the newer shows as well. I do get tired of the current 'fad' of hating Webber. It's tiresome. Sondheim is not 'all that'. Sure, his stuff is great but why is it that you can' enjoy both?? My poor 15 y/o dd, a huge theater nut, has been completely brainwashed by the Stephen Sondheim fanatics. She does nothing but put down anything by Webber, and that's sad. It almost amounts to theater snobbery and that's really tiresome. 'Wicked'? Ah, not a flash in the pan. It has been a great vehicle to involve many people in theater that may not otherwise have been interested. That's the one show that my dh actually agreed to see.
Yeah the staged version of Wicked really took the meat out of the show and made it nothing but fluff. Wicked the novel is very deep, dark and political as are the other books the author (who's name escapes me at the moment) has written in that universe.
Oh please. There are way too many people, the vast majority in fact, that have never and will never read that book. The book just isn't all that great. And yes, I have read Baum's original. Just because something is 'deep and dark' does not automatically mean it is the best thing since sliced bread. Gregory Maguire, by the way.
I'm organizing a trip for 50+ people from our Girl Scout neighborhood to NYC this June. We are going to see The Little Mermaid, so I'm glad Missy1961 enjoyed it!
Next week is a dream Broadway week for me. I'm seeing Jersey Boys in Pittsburgh on Sunday evening (while the entire rest of the city will be watching the Steelers in the Super Bowl

). Then, I head to NYC on Wednesday for a business trip. My coworker and I are going to see Stomp on Wednesday, Avenue Q or Altar Boyz on Thursday, and Mary Poppins on Friday. Can't wait!
Have you looked into a group called StudentsLive? Their website is
www.StudentsLive.net
My dd, 15, is a GS and is heading to NYC this weekend to participate in a 'weekend for good' that these people have put together. They (studentslive) put theater based programs out there for young people. This one is for GSs only. For $185 pp, you go to the Gershwin in the morning, have workshops led by theater personel..not sure how they're going to do that since we're all in the audience, but we'll see. Then, we break for lunch and return for the matinee of 'Wicked' where all the seats were sold to only GSs and those traveling with them.
The big thing is that they asked any of the girls who wished to, to do a project where they went out and did good things....tying the 'I've been changed for the better...' theme of 'Wicked' to the whole GS mentality of public service or doing good things for others. So, my dd did a report on her trip into the inner city of Boston where they worked with the homeless, fed them, and clothed them, after walking the night streets with them, as well as some recovered drug addicts, to listen to their life stories and see how they got there. She submitted her project and was chosen as one of the girls to present her project, onstage, at the Gershwin on Sat. Then, those girls will take part in a Wicked trivia contest, basically dealing with personality traits of Elphaba and Galinda. The girl with the most points gets a backstage tour as well as gets to meet some of the actors and such.
This group puts on many different programs, with different shows. It's worth checking into if your girls want to go as a group.
But, back to the OP posters questions...great idea for a thread by the way CCT.
I don't think I have any true favorites. My taste is way to eclectic. I know we did want to catch Spring Awakening before it closed since we did 'Annie' years ago with Alex Socha, who is now in SA. But, that isn't going to happen. We will have to see it on tour in Boston on Mother's Day..nice way to spend that day!!! With my 15 y/o dd.
Love so many shows. I start rehearsals for Sweeney over the weekend...ensemble for that. I love Carousel, Music Man. Cats? Well, it's not my favorite but it does have some decent music in it.
I have to be one of the few people on the face of the planet who does not love Les Mis. But, I am taking dd to see it while we're in London next month...such a good mom.
Saw Curtains last winter and really enjoyed it.
Spamalot is a huge favorite. I would have said Rent up until last May. Had seen it several times and loved it, but when we saw it over Mem Day weekend, in NYC, the cast was not all that great, the theater in dreadful need of rehab. But, it looks like we'll try to catch it on tour in Boston in July...gotta see Adam and Anthony together again.
We did get to see Gypsy...dd is hugely impressed with LuPone. Me? Not so much. And she did get to actually speak to the diva herself at the stage door. I guess she was okay, but I've enjoyed other's in the part better.
Not sure what else we're going to try to get discount tickets for this weekend. Not much is left. We'll see what happens.