Just back from our March 19-26 eastern cruise and we docked at both islands. At St. Thomas we docked at the new "dock", they have two. I think that it depends on when your ship arrives whether you will dock or not. I didn't see any ships being tendered...2 ships were at our "dock" and I believe there were 4 ships at the old dock. If you could choose a dock, hope for the old one where all the shops are. The new dock is so new that there are no shops there yet.