We were just there in Feb and Beaches and Cream was a must. We were a party of 7 and had to wait a little bit, but you can stroll the grounds then. We had the exact meal everyone is talking about and it is absolutely to die for. My mom in law had the onion rings and I kept having to sneak bites. I still think about them and when we can go back and order them, they were the best. If you love peanut butter, the no way jose sundae is the ultimate!! Our whole family loved the cheeseburgers, definitely not theme park. ENJOY!!!
OMG this is my absolute fave treat in WDW. I'm drooling....
And to answer the OP's question.... YES!!!!!!!!!!! these burgers are way better than anywhere else on property. Think, fresh, made to order, unbelievable the way mom used to make them good.
As a tip go at an "off" time. This is a small old fashioned soda shop and it can be very busy with long waits.